OpinioNet Kosovo War Commentary - Gregory Elich
Topic: Kosovo Reflections
"Yugoslavia Amid The
Maelstrom" The sound was like no other. Hundreds of blackbirds were perched in
trees throughout the park in central Belgrade where our bus stopped, and
their loud and raucous cries startled me. I had never seen so many
blackbirds in one place. Our host, Nikola Moraca, and his son were there
to greet us. When asked about the blackbirds, Nikola replied, "We never
had these before. They are from Kosovo. They migrated here because the
bombing in Kosovo was too intense." The birds' piercing cries were
unsettling, and seemed a harbinger of all of the pain and suffering we
would come to witness during our stay in Yugoslavia. We were a delegation
of peace activists and concerned individuals, organized and led by Barry
Lituchy, a specialist on European history. Our mission was to bring
medical aid to the people of Yugoslavia, and we would spend the first two
weeks of August 1999, in gathering evidence of NATO war crimes for former
U.S. Attorney General Ramsey Clark's Independent Commission of Inquiry.
Years of hardship had taken their toll on Yugoslav society. Burdened by
sanctions, a massive influx of refugees, and NATO's destruction of
factories and workplaces, the unemployment rate has soared. All along
Revolution Boulevard, sidewalks were jammed with street vendors selling
paltry goods. It was an important means of survival for many people in
Belgrade. I saw two very elderly women sitting behind a card table, on
which the only goods were stones, hand painted with designs and
affectionate sayings. Gasoline is strictly rationed, and stations were
usually closed. We frequently saw people standing by roadsides, plastic
bottles of gasoline for sale. Gasoline smuggled across the border from
Bosnia-Herzegovina and Hungary was another means of survival for the
destitute. Buses and streetcars were densely crowded. Windows were sealed
in some streetcars, a sign of air conditioning in better times. Now, the
closed windows served to trap the oppressive summer heat, as people
crowded and pressed against each, soaked with sweat. "The burden of
imposed sanctions is felt in nearly every situation on a daily basis,"
Danka Moraca, Nikola's wife, informed us. "Sanctions have changed our
lives tremendously, if not totally. Now we are all used to shortages of
everyday necessities such as basic food, cleaning products and personal
items. If you are fortunate enough to be able to afford them, you must
wait in long lines." Sanctions, she added, have resulted in a "decline of
salaries, pensions and a general impoverishment of ordinary people."
According to the Yugoslav Red Cross, approximately 100,000 people,
primarily pensioners and welfare recipients, rely on soup kitchens, but
the need outstrips the supply of available meals. Eight years of sanctions
have taken their toll, and the war compounded the effect, nearly doubling
the poverty rate.
On our first morning in Belgrade, we met with Bratislava Morina,
Federal Minister for Refugees, Displaced Persons and Humanitarian Aid. It
was Morina's ministry that was responsible for coping with Europe's
largest refugee population. Already burdened with 700,000 refugees from
wars in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina, more than 200,000 people had fled
from Kosovo by the time of our visit, a number that would soon grow to
over 350,000. Morina, whose husband is Albanian, listed several prominent
political positions held by Albanians in Yugoslavia, "until they were
given orders to leave office" by secessionists "and become part of the
parallel world." - a reference to the secessionist's boycott of
institutions. Calm and dignified, Morina spoke eloquently of the
destruction wrought by NATO, but concluded that these were "not the worst
crimes committed" by President Clinton. "When we hear claims that they
want to create a multiethnic society in Kosovo, this is ironic," she said,
"because we have witnessed one of the most radical ethnic cleansing
campaigns" since the arrival of NATO troops.
We next met with officials of the Yugoslav Red Cross. We gave them
several bags of medicines that were donated by American doctors and
individuals. Dr. Miodrag Starcevic talked of the refugee crisis, pointing
out that "our needs are very urgent," and that they lacked food, shelter,
clothes and medicines for refugees. Officials there felt that the level of
need for humanitarian aid greatly exceeded what international
organizations were providing. Another serious problem for the organization
is that it cannot operate freely in Kosovo. "We cannot go there," Dr.
Starcevic said. "Even when we send humanitarian relief, we must provide in
advance for some kind of escort by KFOR [NATO's Kosovo Force], because it
is impossible to go there. It is too dangerous." Medical officer Ljubisa
Dragisic told us that local production met most of the nation's needs for
drugs and medical supplies, but that sanctions caused shortages in
imported medicines. "It's especially a problem with some services," she
said. "For example, the transfusion service, because we import the bags
and blood tests, and some drugs...oncology drugs, and some programs for
example, the dialysis program, and a part of the program for treatment of
diabetics." Suture material and anesthetic drugs were also in short
supply.
Poisoning an Entire Nation and People
We were particularly interested in learning more about the
environmental aspect of NATO bombing. The systematic destruction of
chemical, petrochemical, fertilizer plants, and oil refineries seriously
poisoned the local environment. In the early morning hours of April 18,
1999, NATO missiles rained down on the industrial town of Pancevo, just
northeast of Belgrade. A petrochemical plant was hit, sending into the
atmosphere 900 tons of vinyl chloride monomers (VCM), an extremely
dangerous carcinogen. By sunrise, clouds of VCM poured through the town,
at levels exceeding 10,600 times the permissible limit for human safety.
Burning VCM released phosgene gas, a substance that was used as a poison
gas during the First World War. Chlorine gas - also used as a poison gas
during World War I - was also discharged by fires a the plant, as were
other dangerous chemicals, such as naptha, ethylene dichloride and
hydrochloric acid. A poison rain spattered the region, and hundreds of
tons of oil and chemicals soaked into the soil and poured into the Danube
River. Pools of mercury formed on the grounds of the plant. After a
missile narrowly missed striking a tank of liquid ammonia, panicked
workers dumped the liquid ammonia into the Danube in order to avert a
terrible tragedy. The entire population of Pancevo was evacuated
immediately, but they have since returned to live in the town. Doctors
there advise women to avoid pregnancy for the next two years, and many
residents are coming down with red rashes and blisters. Although we were
only in Pancevo for a few hours, some of us, myself included, found rashes
appearing on our legs before the end of the day. My lower legs were
covered with rashes, and it was two weeks before they would finally
disappear. According to one worker we talked with, eighty percent of the
petrochemical plant was destroyed. Another worker told us that "vast
quantities of ammonia and VCM spilled into the river," and that he could
"see an immediate effect because one meter above the river the bank
appears burned. All the plants look as if they had been burned by fire."
Several people expressed fears for their health and that of their
families.
Serious environmental hazards also resulted from the destruction of
power plants in Bor and Kragujevac. Transformers there relied on
transformer oil containing polychlorinated biphenyles (PCB) pyralene, as a
coolant. According to the Regional Environmental Centre for Central and
Eastern Europe, "one liter of the PCB pyralene pollutes one billion liters
of water." We visited an oil refinery in Novi Sad. One resident of Novi
Sad, whose home was located a mere three blocks from the refinery, later
told me that the refinery was bombed on virtually a daily basis and that
his neighborhood was constantly enveloped in smoke. Outside the refinery,
we saw a struggling bird soaked in oil, near death
Perhaps the deadliest weapon in NATO's arsenal was depleted uranium
(DU) tipped missiles and bombs. Depleted uranium's high density enables
projectiles to easily penetrate armor and concrete targets. When DU
weapons impact on their target, thousands of radioactive particles are
released into the atmosphere, and may be borne for miles by the wind. When
people ingest these particles, serious bodily damage can result. Following
the 1991 Gulf War, rates of birth defects and leukemia rose dramatically
in southern Iraq.
Barry and I talked with Dr. Radoje Lausevic, an environmental
specialist and assistant professor at the University of Belgrade. Dr.
Lausevic's appearance and manner of speech reminded me of my best friend,
Jorge, so he made an immediately favorable impression. While driving us in
his car, he commented on the ecological impact of the war, and it wasn't
until we arrived at our destination that I realized that his talk was so
interesting that I forgot to record him or take notes. We arrived at the
office of the Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern
Europe, where we briefly finished our discussion of the environmental
damage. Barry asked about depleted uranium (DU) weapons. My impression was
that use of depleted uranium weapons was limited to Kosovo, but Dr.
Lausevic told us that Russian sources determined that 30 tons of DU was
used outside of Kosovo. The entire territory of Yugoslavia was exposed to
these weapons. One particle of DU in the lungs, he said, is equivalent to
a daily chest x-ray for life.
The delegation also met with Dusan Vasiljevic, president of Green
Table, a Belgrade-based environmental non-governmental organization. A man
with an elegant manner of speech, he also acted as our guide and
translator when we visited Pancevo. Vasiljevic told us that 135,000 tons
of toxic chemicals spilled into the environment as a result of NATO
bombing. Speaking of Pancevo, he pointed out that VCM "is one of the most
dangerous toxic chemicals that ever existed. It's gastro organic in the
first place, and disrupts the cells inside," the consequences of which are
"liver disease, kidney disease and of course cancer itself." Vasiljevic
also confirmed Dr. Lausevic's report of widespread use of DU weapons.
Vasiljevic explained that as DU particles spread over an area, it "enters
the food chain, as well as to water, soil, even in the air. Once you get
these depleted uranium particles in your body, they stay there. You can't
get rid of them. And they move in your body...mostly they go to the
kidneys, and also to the liver." Vasiljevic's comments on Kosovo were
sobering. "Kosovo itself is a nuclear desert now. I wouldn't go there
myself...because the level of radiation in Kosovo is over any tolerable
level." Depleted uranium emits primarily alpha radiation, which is 20
times more deadly than gamma radiation, he said. The United Nations Balkan
Task Force, as well as other Western investigators "did not find any
increased radiation. How could they say so? Because they did not have the
proper equipment for that....They had just a Geiger counter." A Geiger
counter is worthless for measuring DU because it measures primarily gamma
radiation, not alpha.
Exhaust from NATO overflights, Vasiljevic claimed, severely damaged the
ozone layer above Yugoslavia. Immediately following NATO's bombing
campaign, Yugoslavia was ravaged by a series of floods and severe
rainstorms. By the time of our visit, the temperature was searing,
unbearable at times. People speculated that the heat, floods and rains
were a result of the thinning of the ozone. The damaged ozone layer would
soon drift over Western Europe, Vasiljevic said. It is difficult to
determine a correlation, but on December 2, 1999, the European Space
Agency reported that the lowest ever levels of ozone, "nearly as low as
those found in the Antarctic," were measured over northwest Europe during
November. Everyone was concerned about the food supply. Danka worried that
"all that we have on the green markets or in the shops nowadays has been
contaminated, either by the destroyed chemical industry or by the new
weapons dropped on our heads. I can't even think about the possible
consequences of consuming such food."
A City Crippled by Bombs
In the northern city of Novi Sad, we viewed three bridges across the
Danube River. All three were severed by NATO missiles. The Varadin Bridge
carried a main water pipe, and when the bridge was destroyed on April 1,
the Petrovaradin section of the city lost its water supply. Similarly,
destruction of the Zezelj Bridge on April 26 eliminated water in the
suburbs. Water had to be trucked in until service could be restored. At
the Executive Council Building in Novi Sad, we met Dr. Zivorad Smiljanic,
president of the Assembly of the Autonomous Province of Vojvodina, and an
interesting and knowledgeable man. Smiljanic pointed out, as did many
others during our visit, that Yugoslavia has 26 nationalities and is a
multiethnic society. "Even the smallest nationalities have education in
their own mother tongue," he said. "Now you can see for yourselves what
NATO did." NATO leaders "constantly talk about democracy, but we could see
that democracy in action here: democracy that bombed and destroyed
bridges, schools and hospitals....all these aims were actually false,
because the real truth and their real aim was to conquer everything and
put everything under one system." Smiljanic was asked to name their most
urgent need. "The thing that we would like most of all is for the
international community to leave us alone;" he exclaimed, "to lift
blockades and sanctions, and stop 'helping' us in the way that they are
doing."
Following the meeting, one official walked up to Barry. His eyes were
moist. "It was such a difficult time for those of us with children," he
said. "We didn't know what to do: take both children in one cellar, or put
them in separate cellars." A terrible dilemma, whether to keep the family
together and risk losing everyone in a single moment; or split the family
apart, thus increasing the chances of losing someone.
We were scheduled to tour and view bomb damage at the Executive Council
building later in the day. When we returned, our bus pulled to a stop in
front of the building and our delegation began to disembark. A woman
walked up to our bus, and asked us through an open window, "Are you a
delegation?" Receiving an affirmative answer, she spoke in an angry and
outraged tone, "We're a delegation from Germany. We've been here one week
already. We've seen such terrible things, you can't imagine. People here
have a system like no one in the world. It's a true multiethnic society.
Back in Germany, all we hear are lies. There is no way to get the truth
out." We soon came to share her reaction and her outrage. The portrayal of
Yugoslavia in Western media is bizarre for anyone who troubles himself to
actually visit the place. A multiethnic society where peoples of many
nationalities work and live together is painted as racist. A society in
which women walk calmly and unafraid in a park at midnight, as we
regularly saw, is portrayed as crime-ridden. Knowledgeable and worldly
people are represented as ignorant and irrational. How often had I read in
the Western press of President Slobodan Milosevic's 1989 speech at Kosovo
Polje, in which it was claimed that he whipped the crowd into a
nationalist frenzy with a language of hate? Western reporters can get away
with such monstrous lies because they know no one will bother to check the
text of that speech. I couldn't believe the accusation because it ran
counter to those speeches I was familiar with. When I found a copy of the
speech, my suspicions were confirmed. There was not one nationalist phrase
and not one phrase of hatred. What I found instead were phrases such as,
"Serbia has never had only Serbs living in it. Today, more than in the
past, members of other peoples and nationalities also live in it. This is
not a disadvantage for Serbia. I am truly convinced that it is its
advantage." Or these examples: "Socialism in particular, being a
progressive and just democratic society, should not allow people to be
divided in the national and religious respect," and "Yugoslavia is a
multiethnic community and it can survive only under the conditions of full
equality for all nations that live in it." These are the phrases the
Western media would have one believe are filled with hate and racism. When
I returned to the United States, it was weeks before I could bear to
listen to the news, and its spewing of lies and focusing on trivial
issues.
Whatever else would happen during our stay in Yugoslavia, it was clear
that we would be well fed. Every morning and evening, Nikola and Danka
prepared a spectacular banquet for us. We were continually delighted by a
dazzling array of delicious dishes. Their extraordinary hospitality and
kindness made me feel like part of their family, and Nikola's impish sense
of humor brought daily merriment. The importance of family and friends was
paramount in this society. Friends, family, and neighbors often visited.
On the street, we often saw family members holding hands. Displays of
affection were open. Due to sanctions, their lives were materially
impoverished compared to earlier times, but still they lead rich lives. As
one man in Novi Sad told me, "We have a different philosophy here than in
the West. We have a saying, 'The man is rich who has many friends."
NATO did not ignore Vidovdan Skonaselje, a suburb of Novi Sad. People
were living in the ruins of their homes, simply because they had no where
else to go. The home of Rajko and Gordana Matic was severely damaged.
Rajko and his wife Gordana fled Zagreb in 1992 and built their new home
here. Now NATO had bombed their new house. Heavy plastic covered the
windows. With the exception of the frame and base, nothing remained of the
roof. The explosion had dented and twisted their car. They allowed us
inside to view their home. Holes in the walls, a result of the bomb blast,
allowed chickens to enter and wander about. On the second floor, one of
the interior walls, broken and cracked, was bowed to an alarming degree,
like the letter 'C'. Light streamed in through a ruptured wall, and mounds
of rubble filled the rooms. It didn't seem safe, but they had no where
else to go, nor money to repair the damage. Previous Western visitors had
promised them help, which never came. To the left of the Matic's house
stood an empty shell of another home. Only the brick walls still stood.
Everything else was blown away in the bombing. Farther to the left, the
roof of a demolished home angled down to the ground. Behind it stood more
homes with blasted roofs, damaged walls and seared interiors. The house to
the right was missing the second floor. Only remnants of the front and
back wall remained. Hammering sounds told us that the owners had begun the
arduous task of rebuilding. Across the street, the roof of one home was a
mass of twisted wreckage. Between these buildings, a roadside sign listed
at a drunken angle, punctured neatly by shrapnel from a NATO bomb. It was
a "welcome" sign.
NATO also left its calling card at another suburb of Novi Sad,
Detelinara. On May 6, a powerful bomb landed at the juncture of two
apartment buildings and the Svetozar Markovic elementary school. By the
time of our visit, the huge crater had been filled in, and all 20 of the
demolished automobiles removed. The buildings were severely damaged, and
many apartments were devastated. Seven people were wounded in the attack,
and the site followed a pattern that we would witness repeatedly during
our two weeks in Yugoslavia. Residential areas with no military value were
targeted on a regular basis.
Belgrade Bombarded
In New Belgrade, the more recently built section of the city, we
stopped at Hotel Yugoslavia. On May 7, just before midnight, two NATO
missiles struck the hotel near the main entrance. One person was killed,
and four wounded. It was impossible to view the extensive destruction
without contemplating the mentality that could order missiles to be fired
at a hotel. As we stood before the Chinese embassy, only a few blocks
away, NATO's excuses seemed absurd. Architecturally distinctive, the
embassy's unique beauty could not possibly be mistaken for the nearby
Federal Directorate of Supply, nor any other building in the vicinity.
Similarly difficult to swallow was the claim that the embassy was bombed
because the CIA had relied on an old map. The embassy building was built
during 1992-93, and an old map would have shown an empty field. One would
have to believe that NATO intended to bomb an empty field. Certainly, the
CIA would have closely monitored the Chinese embassy in Belgrade,
particularly as NATO prepared to wage war on Yugoslavia. Three
satellite-guided missiles struck the embassy, just twenty minutes after
the bombing of Hotel Yugoslavia. The missile that did the most damage
penetrated through the roof, burrowing down to the basement. Three people
were killed, and 20 wounded. Fire and smoke poured through the building.
The stairways were demolished, and people trapped on the top three floors
tied bedsheets together, hanging them out of windows as a means of escape.
We saw that one rope of bedsheets still hung from a fourth story window.
Two days before my departure for Yugoslavia, I obtained a copy of an
article from the July 2 issue of Kai Fang, published in Hong Kong. The
article's author, Su Lan, wrote that embassy personnel electronically
monitored NATO's military operations, and that NATO feared that the
downing of its F-117 Stealth fighter-bomber may have been a result of
information passed along by them to Yugoslav officials. The October 17
issue of The Observer, and follow-up story a few weeks later, confirmed
that the embassy was deliberately targeted. A NATO flight controller based
in Naples told The Observer, "The Chinese embassy had an electronic
profile, which NATO located and pinpointed." "The aim," said another NATO
officer, "was to send a clear message to Milosevic that he should not use
outside help in the shape of the Chinese."
Not far away, the ruins of another beautiful building stood, the
23-story Uzce Business Center, the target of four missiles on April 21.
Much of the building's exterior was blackened by fire, and many windows
were a mass of twisted metal. I remembered seeing dramatic photographs of
this building engulfed in flames. NATO planners anticipated high
"collateral damage." Their plans anticipated that up to 100 government
officials and 250 civilians residing in nearby apartments in the "expected
blast radius" would be killed in the attack. Unfazed at the prospect of
murdering up to 350 people, President Clinton and British Prime Minister
Tony Blair gave their approval for the building's destruction. The Uzce
Business Center housed offices of a variety of businesses and political
organizations. The rationale for the building's destruction was that some
of the offices belonged to the Serbian Socialist Party and the closely
allied Yugoslav United Left. Only evacuation of the building averted a
terrible tragedy, and no one perished in the attack.
NATO's bland assertions seemed obscene. Bombing the Chinese embassy was
an "accident," and therefore excusable. This carried with it an unspoken
assumption, that bombing another building and killing Yugoslav civilians
would be acceptable. The destruction of Hotel Yugoslavia and the Uzce
Business Center was also acceptable, because these somehow fell into the
all-inclusive category of "military targets." Many people in the West were
completely indifferent to the death and destruction carried out in their
names. All of NATO's claims were accepted without examination or
questioning. The United States, it is assumed, has an inherent right to
invade or bomb another country and to trample international law underfoot.
In this context, I found it poignant when we saw a billboard in Belgrade,
which read: "They believe in bombs. We believe in God."
That night, in the Moraca's home, delegation member Ken Freeland
interviewed Nenad Gudjic, a Serbian refugee from Kosovo. Gudjic said he
felt that "Albanians suppressed me, especially when I started to date my
present wife, who is Albanian." His wife also felt strong pressure from
Albanian extremists, prompting them to leave Kosovo. "Something very
interesting is happening now," Gudjic said. "I lived in Pristina for 33
years. Now, on the streets of Belgrade, I saw a few of my Albanian friends
who escaped, as I escaped, from Pristina. They are living now in Belgrade
without any problems. These are ethnic Albanians of my generation who
escaped that chaos."
Every Federal building in downtown Belgrade bore the scars of bombing.
Almost every day we passed these buildings, and each day the sight was as
painful as the day before. Late one night during the war, kept awake by an
air raid, Nikola was on his balcony talking to his neighbor across the
street on her balcony. The sound of flying missiles interrupted their
conversation. Nikola shouted at his neighbor, "Get down. This one will hit
us. His shoulders rose as a chill travelled down the back of his neck and
then two explosions roared. Only a few short blocks away, one missile
smashed a house on Maxim Gorky Street, also damaging an adjoining
apartment building and a restaurant. The other missile struck a street
nearby. Four people were injured; one of whom, 23-year old Sofija
Jovanovic, died of her wounds two days later. On my last day in Belgrade,
I walked down to view the site. Nothing remained but a mound of concrete,
bricks, broken boards, and upturned earth. As a sort of memorial, someone
had scrawled graffiti on the remnants of an adjacent building: "Bombed
April 30." With fatalistic humor, graffiti on another house read, "Sorry.
You missed us." Danka described life during the bombing. "We were bombed
constantly for 78 days and nights, without any break or pause. We were
without water or electricity for days. We had to throw away everything
from the refrigerator, including all medicaments essential for our family,
because of the high temperatures in May. The bombing was awful, cruel and
savage. We were all afraid, staying in the dark lobby for hours, listening
to the scary sounds of the low-flying warplanes, detonations, children
crying, car alarms, and people screaming who simply couldn't stand it
anymore." Later in the war, "NATO changed its tactics, and by the end they
were bombing us every two hours. That was part of their psychological war,
I suppose." The effects of the bombardment were widespread. "There was no
bread. The bakeries couldn't produce bread without electricity. The smell
of spoiled food spread from nearby supermarkets. There was no milk for
children." Her children were upset, asking, "Why are those people bombing
us? Why do they hate us so much when we didn't do anything wrong to them?"
Danka revealed that every time she kissed her children goodnight "during
the bombing campaign, deep inside me I was praying for God to see them
healthy and alive the next morning. During those long bombing nights, they
were awakened so many times by strong nearby explosions, annoyed and
panicked."
The Belgrade 5 transformer station of the Serbian Electric Company is
located at Bezanijska Kosa in New Belgrade. It was bombed, as were many
other electrical power and transformer stations. Several Tomahawk missiles
struck here, as well as a new weapon, the CBU-94, a cluster bomb which
releases a web of carbon-graphite threads, resulting in electrical
short-circuits, and burnt components. At one point, seventy percent of
Yugoslavia's power supply was knocked out, which also adversely affected
water supplies that depended on electrical pumps. About 50,000 hospital
patients, including those on dialysis and babies in incubators, also
suffered from the power outages. When workers proved adept at restoring
power rapidly, NATO then targeted the plants with cruise missiles and
conventional bombs. By the end of the war, one third of the electricity
transmission systems were damaged or destroyed. During our visit to
Belgrade 5, workers were busily repairing the damage. We talked with one
of the workers, who said that most of the Belgrade suburb of Zemun was
without electricity. He worried about the onset of winter, when people
would have to rely on alternative sources of heat, such as coal and small
heaters. He pointed out that the coolant for the plant's transformers
contained PCBs, and that consequently, "when the fuel burns, it is toxic,
so [NATO] poisoned nature around here also. It went into the ground, so it
will reach our water supplies." One of our delegation members, Jeff
Goldberg, asked him if this was the most expensive damage inflicted on
Yugoslavia, and the worker immediately responded, "The most expensive
damage is that they killed a lot of people." When asked about the length
of time required for repair, the worker answered. "We need equipment. We
need spare parts...without foreign aid we are dead. We have a factory that
makes spare parts, converters, but...they can make only one switch per
month. It's a low capacity factory." The previous day, due to bomb damage,
virtually all of Serbia's steam power plants shut down, and much of the
country was left without power. On the day of our visit, a breakdown at
the power line at the Djerdap-Bor hydroelectric plant caused a
chain-reaction of breakdowns in other power lines, resulting in more
blackouts. It was expected that hundreds of thousands of people would
freeze during winter, with sanctions blocking the import of much-needed
parts, but prospects improved due to a remarkable program of
reconstruction and improvisation. Electricity is severely rationed, with
frequent power cuts. But what seemed an inevitable humanitarian disaster
has been averted through the ingenuity and heroic efforts of workers in
overcoming seemingly insurmountable obstacles. The electrical worker we
talked with summed up the war: "We were bombed because we refuse to be
slaves. We are a proud people and we don't want to be enslaved. Rich
people want slaves. They want obedient people."
Our meeting with the Belgrade-based Committee for Compiling Data on
Crimes against Humanity and International Law was of particular interest
for me. I had read several articles about the work of the committee as
well as interviews with its president, Dr. Zoran Stankovic, so I was
familiar with the meticulous and significant work they had done in
Bosnia-Herzegovina and Croatia. All nine members of the committee work on
a volunteer basis, constrained by severely limited resources, outmoded
personal computers and only one copy machine. The committee was tasked to
investigate NATO war crimes, and that was the main focus of our
discussion. A point of frustration for the committee was that they had
submitted eight files of documentation with The Hague War Crimes Tribunal,
which treated their reports with complete disinterest.
Albanian Refugees and Civil War: Behind the Media Screen
NATO officials accused the Yugoslav government of expelling its
Albanian population and committing genocide. The flood of refugees pouring
into Albania and Macedonia was trumpeted as justification for bombing
Yugoslavia. Few dwelled on the logical fallacy of NATO's claim that a
refugee crisis which occurred subsequent to bombing was itself the
motivation for that bombing. Western leaders presented a simple picture,
one easily grasped. Reality is seldom as simple as a Hollywood action
movie, though, and Western leaders intentionally distorted events for an
uncritical public.
Every nationality can be found in the membership of the Serbian
Socialist Party, including Albanian, and the party has long prided itself
on a commitment to a multiethnic society. This commitment is evident in
its program and in virtually every document and every speech. Toward the
end of 1998, during the period of the OSCE Mission in Kosovo, the Yugoslav
government set up 14 centers throughout Kosovo, where people could come
and take free lumber and building supplies for reconstruction of homes
damaged in the civil war. These supplies were open to every person of
every nationality. There were no restrictions. It was impossible for me to
believe that the Serbian Socialist Party metamorphosed overnight into a
racist organization, bent on national exclusivity. It did not fit, so I
dug into the matter, trying to ascertain the truth among a torrent of
lies. A more subtle picture emerged, still with suffering on a mass scale,
but this time with NATO as the central catalyst. According to an
intelligence report from the German Foreign Office, dated January 12,
1999, "Even in Kosovo an explicit political persecution linked to Albanian
ethnicity is not verifiable...actions of the security forces [are] not
directed against the Kosovo Albanians as an ethnically defined group, but
against the military opponent and its actual or alleged supporters." A
civil war was raging in the province of Kosovo between the Albanian
secessionist Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) and Yugoslav security forces.
This internal document presented a very different message than Western
leaders' public statements.
Concomitant with NATO's bombing campaign, hundreds of thousands of
people of all nationalities fled their homes. When the first bombs fell,
extremists became enraged and blamed Albanians for the bombing. Many of
these extremists formed paramilitary groups and criminal gangs, and vented
their rage on the local Albanian population. NATO's bombs created an
environment of anarchy and chaos that allowed thugs, paramilitary gangs,
and renegade police to operate freely. One Serbian official was reported
as saying, "It was a catastrophe. Podujevo was emptied in about three
hours. There were a lot of vile and angry people, maddened, who were out
of control." In Kosovo's capital city of Pristina, the first wave of
refugees departed when threatened by thugs during the week and a half
following NATO's first bombs on March 24. The second wave left when the
center of the city was bombed on April 6 and 7, and the third wave left
later, out of a panic that something may happen. Zoran Andjelkovic,
president of the then governing Provisional Executive Council for Kosovo,
pointed out that the first ten days or so of chaos included fierce clashes
among angry civilians. Criminal gangs ran wild, ordering people to leave
so that their homes could be robbed. Both Albanian and Serbian criminal
gangs roamed the region. Adrian Gillan, in an article in the London Review
of Books, talked with Ben Ward, a researcher for Human Rights Watch. Ward
told him, "There doesn't appear to be anything to support allegations of
mass killings. It is generally paramilitaries who are responsible. It
doesn't seem organized. There appear to be individual acts of sadism
rather than anything else. There seems not to be any policy or
instruction, but that isn't to say that people have not been given the
latitude to kill. However, I don't think at this stage we have anything
that adds up to the systematic killing of civilians." Restoring order was
an extremely difficult task for the Yugoslav Army and security forces
because they were under constant NATO bombardment. Yet, by the third week
of the war they had succeeded in restoring order in much of the region,
and in the latter half of April, Yugoslav police began escorting refugees
back to their homes. By the time Yugoslav troops and security forces
withdrew from Kosovo in early June, they had arrested over 800 thugs and
paramilitaries for crimes against civilians.
At the beginning of the war, Yugoslav troops evacuated villages along
the border with Albania where KLA bunkers and arms depots where found, but
they were under orders not to harm civilians in the process. An invasion
by NATO troops was anticipated, and as one Yugoslav soldier explained,
"You can't be waiting for the American army and at the same time have
armed Albanians behind your back." In an interview for UPI conducted
during the war, Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic said, "Our regular
forces are highly disciplined. The paramilitary irregular forces are a
different story. Bad things happened, as they did with both sides during
the Vietnam war, or any other war for that matter. We have arrested those
irregular self-appointed leaders. Some have already been tried and
sentenced to 20 years in prison."
People fled for other reasons as well. There was a clear pattern of
people fleeing areas subjected to intensive bombardment. Some of the
refugees Ben Ward talked with said they had fled from NATO bombs. Other
refugees fled to escape being caught in battles between Yugoslav and KLA
forces. Thousands more fled to avoid forcible conscription into KLA ranks.
Every Albanian man KLA soldiers encountered was forced to enlist. Those
who refused were either savagely beaten or killed.
Refugee flight, though, was never as thorough as painted by NATO
propaganda, and hundreds of thousands of Albanians remained in Kosovo.
Paramilitary rage swept through portions of the western region, while much
of the remainder of the province was unscathed. Even during the period of
bombing, many thousands of Albanian refugees returned to their homes.
The web of lies spun by the NATO propaganda machine started to unravel
once KFOR entered the province. Claiming that there would be half a
million internally displaced people inside the province, KFOR instead
found only small isolated pockets of refugees. "We planned for what we
thought was a potential disaster...and we just haven't found it," admitted
Lt. General Mike McDuffie. Lurid tales of mass genocide fell apart, as
forensic specialists investigated suspected mass graves. Up to 700 bodies
were said to be hidden in the Trepca lead and zinc mines. Not one body was
found there. About 350 were buried in a mass grave in Ljubenic, the public
was told. A thorough examination of the site found only seven. The leader
of the Spanish Forensic team, Emilio Perez Pujo, was told that his team
would go to the "worst zone of Kosovo," and to "prepare ourselves to
perform more than 2,000 autopsies." But, "the result is very different. We
only found 187 cadavers." "There were no mass graves" in his team's area,
he said. "For the most part the Serbs are not as bad as they have been
painted." Faced with increasingly embarrassing questions about the lack of
evidence for NATO's justification for military aggression, The Hague war
crimes tribunal scrambled to release a statement asserting that they had
indeed found 2,108 bodies. Far short of genocide, but certainly more than
individual reports of excavations would indicate. Significantly, the
tribunal neglected to categorize these deaths. We are not told how many
bodies of each nationality were found, how many died from executions, how
many were KLA or Yugoslav soldiers killed in combat, how many died from
NATO bombs, and how many died from natural causes.
NATO claimed that its intervention was necessary to quell the civil war
in Kosovo, while neglecting to reveal its role in creating and escalating
the conflict. A September 24, 1998 report on the Monitor television
program on German ARD Television Network, revealed that the German Federal
Intelligence Service [BND] was engaged in "several illegal arms supplies"
to Albania, in cooperation with the Military Counter Intelligence Service
[MAD], and that "via these channels" military equipment was supplied to
the KLA. An ex-MAD official claimed that orders for the illegal arms
shipments were issued "from the very top." Several monitors from the
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) patrolling
Kosovo during 1998-99 were CIA officers, revealed The Times on March 12,
2000. Their function was to provide advice and training manuals to the
KLA. The same article reports that Shaban Shala, a KLA commander, met
British, American and Swiss intelligence agents in northern Albanian as
early as 1996. According to Belgrade's Politika Ekspres, "a leak from
well-informed circles in the [secessionist] Democratic League of Kosovo"
disclosed that during a meeting between US envoy Richard Holbrooke and KLA
officers at Junik on June 26, 1998, Holbrooke promised the KLA $10 million
for the purchase of U.S. arms. One week later, Albanian media reported
mysterious flights of U.S. C-130 cargo planes landing at Gjadar airport in
northern Albania, a region under the control of the KLA. None of the
flights were reported to Albanian air traffic controllers, causing alarm
over potential collisions. Paul Beaver, an editor at Jane's Defence Weekly
was told by a Pentagon source, "Even before the air strikes seemed
inevitable, a [Military Professional Resources - MPRI] team was there [in
Kosovo] giving basic military training in tactics to the KLA field
commanders." MPRI is an organization of ex-US military officers that is
contracted by the Pentagon to provide training to foreign armed forces
when it is politically awkward for the U.S. government to be seen as
directly involved. KLA bunkers captured by Yugoslav forces often turned up
sophisticated Western weapons and U.S. food tins and medical packs.
The Fate of the Roma (Gypsy) People in Kosovo
On August 6, we visited Zemun and met with Jovan Damjanovic, president
of the Federal Association of Roma (Gypsy) People in Yugoslavia. A
passionate man, Damjanovic described the horrors visited upon his
community by the KLA following the occupation of the province by KFOR.
Once Yugoslav forces withdrew, there was nothing to restrain the KLA from
pursuing its policy of murdering and driving out every non-Albanian ethnic
group, and every non-secessionist Albanian. Under the protective umbrella
of KFOR, the KLA went on a murderous rampage, killing or expelling
virtually everyone who opposed it and leaving in its wake a trail of
burning homes.
Damjanovic told us that the European Union had issued a list of 300
Yugoslav citizens who it banned from travel outside of Yugoslavia. The
United States and several other nations also joined in imposing the travel
restrictions. Individuals whose names are on the list and who have
investments or accounts outside of Yugoslavia had those assets seized.
U.S. intelligence agents visited many of the people on the list, implying
that their names could be removed from the list if they cooperated with
Western attempts to overthrow the democratically elected government of
Yugoslavia. There were also hints that uncooperative individuals would
face trumped-up war crimes charges. Right-wing opposition leader Vuk
Draskovic is not on the list, but he also was told he would face war
crimes charges if he did not join the U.S. effort to topple the
government, an assignment he readily accepted. Almost the entire
government of Yugoslavia is on the list, as well as many prominent people
in the society. On December 6, 1999, the list was expanded to 590 names,
and more than two months later, on February 28, an additional 180 names
were added. Looking over the list of names, I recognized several people we
had met, such as Commissioner for Refugees, Displaced Persons and
Humanitarian Aid Bratislava Morina and President of the Vojvodina Assembly
Zivorad Smiljanic. In Smiljanic's case, Western officials supposedly knew
enough about him to add him to the list, but not enough to spell his name
correctly. Only a full reading of the list can bring a full understanding
of its vindictive nature. Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic's
daughter-in-law is on the list. The Minister of Sport, apparently, also
bears guilt, as do the Minister of Tourism and the Minister of Family
Care. Also punished is the owner of a fashion-clothing store, the owner of
a watch company, bankers, family members of a banker, and the Secretary of
the Red Cross. In short, anyone of any prominence who has not lent himself
or herself to the Western project to impose a puppet government is treated
as a criminal. On September 17, 1999, Damjanovic issued a statement
condemning the KLA's pogrom against non-Albanians in Kosovo. "This state
of affairs calls into question the justification for the foreign
presence," the statement declared, and "the exodus of Serbs, Montenegrins,
and the Romanies continues on the lines of the Nazi scenario of fifty
years ago, while the world looks on." It was a strong statement, but also
a cry from the heart. Damjanovic's organization faced the daunting task of
providing housing and aid for the mass exodus of Roma people from Kosovo.
His plea did not go unnoticed in the West. On December 6, he too, was
added to the EU's travel ban list. Now the president of the Roma people in
Yugoslavia, too, is a criminal.
We were driven to a Roma settlement in Zemun Polje, on the outskirts of
Zemun. Romany residents here and in Zemun itself had taken into their
homes over 5,000 refugees. Coping with this influx placed a considerable
strain on the local population. Those who had little still opened their
arms to help their fellow human beings. It said much for the people, and I
was deeply impressed. This was a poor neighborhood, and several of the
homes demonstrated an ingenuity for improvised construction with found
materials that reminded me of a similar resourcefulness found among poor
residents of Bangkok. One home in particular fascinated me, with what
appeared to be a fur-covered roof, and a fur tail waving aloft from a pole
protruding from the roof. The moment our cars pulled to a stop, a crowd
gathered. We interviewed several Roma and Egyptian refugees; people who
had lost everything. Krasnic Tefiq brought his family here from Obilic
after KLA soldiers came to his house and threatened to kill him and his
family. For two months they had nowhere to sleep until a family here took
them in, but life was still hard. "We have no food," he told us, "We are
starving. We are begging in the streets for food." Puco Rezeza's
experience was similar. His brother was killed by the KLA, and KLA
soldiers threatened to kill him and his family if they did not leave. He
too told us he was starving. We interviewed several more people, but when
emotions flared, Damjanovic decided to cut short the interviews. As our
cars departed, children ran excitedly behind us, enveloped in the dust
kicked up by our cars. We passed two boys standing by the side of the
road, who pumped their fists in the air, and chanted, "Yugoslavia!
Yugoslavia!"
We resumed our interviews the next day in Zemun. We were surrounded and
pressed on all sides by a crowd of refugees, all anxious to tell us their
stories and to hear each other's. The heat was sweltering, and sweat
poured down my back. Estrep Ramadanovic, vice president of the Roma
association, told us that 120,000 out of 150,000 Roma people had been
expelled from Kosovo. Ramadanovic himself had taken 20 refugees into his
home. "The KLA soldiers don't want any other ethnic group to be in
Kosovo," he told us, "Only Albanians." Bajrosha Dulaj was angry. "My
daughter, Anesi Akmeti, was raped by KLA soldiers. At night we were
sleeping in our house, and KLA soldiers broke in and dragged my daughter
out and raped her." Her family's only remaining possessions were the
clothes they wore on the day they were driven from Kosovo. "I am sleeping
on the street," she said, "I have nowhere to stay. I have no food. I have
no clothes." The period of bombing was nightmarish for them. "The children
have been afraid since the NATO bombing. They are afraid of
airplanes....every night they wake up every two or three hours and they
are crying."
Adan Berisha survived KLA torture. He showed us his wife, who was also
tortured by KLA soldiers. It appeared as if acid had been poured on her
face and arm. The KLA killed their 12-year-old son, Idis, as well as
Adan's father and two of his uncles. "A KLA soldier gave us only three
hours to leave our home," Adan said, "or he would kill us." His voice was
filled with anguish as he concluded, "Sorrow. A world of sorrow."
"KLA soldiers took everything, all my furniture from my home," Rakmani
Elis told us, "and then they burned down my house." Rakmani expressed
himself with a passion that swept all before it. "I'm not against the
American people," he exclaimed, "but this decision they made strikes me as
lunatic. The rights of every people, the Serb, the Montenegrin and the
Gypsy, have been annulled. People are going out to kill, but you, as an
army," - referring to KFOR - "just sit there. Did you come here to help or
to watch this circus going on? Events now are making history. It is not
acceptable what the American people are doing to us. If they came to help,
let me see them help. But if they did not come here to help, then
everyone, Serbs and Gypsies, will be stamped out."
KLA solders had dragged Aysha Shatili and her children from her home,
and started removing her furniture. "I called three British KFOR soldiers
for help. They came, but did nothing," she said. Her son was stabbed in
the back when he attempted to stop the KLA soldiers from looting their
home. Her two houses were then burned down. Like most of the refugees, she
too owned only the clothes she wore on the day she was driven from her
home.
Five KLA soldiers visited Hasim Berisha, looking for his brother. "They
told me I have just five minutes to produce my brother or they will kill
my entire family." He left immediately and went to his sister's house. His
sister reported the incident to British KFOR headquarters, where they told
her to go wherever she wants to go, just so she won't be killed. Hasim
checked on his house the following day, and saw that it had been burned
down. His brother was caught by the KLA and severely beaten, and he too
was forced to flee the province.
Abdullah Shefik was fleeing from Urosevac in his van when KLA soldiers
stopped him and ordered him to leave his van with them. "American KFOR
soldiers stood nearby when my van was hijacked," he said, "but they did
nothing." All of his belongings were in the van.
Becet Kotesi told us that when British and French KFOR troops entered
Gnjilane, KLA soldiers "attacked Serbian and Roma people. KFOR did nothing
because they were on the other side of town, but the town is not very big,
so they had to know what was happening." Kotesi was in a pharmacy when the
shooting began, and promptly left to ride his bicycle home. "Three hundred
meters behind me was another man riding a bicycle, and KLA soldiers threw
a grenade at him and killed him." Kotesi fled the province because "KLA
soldiers searched for my compatriots, to beat and kill them, because many
fought against them as members of the Yugoslav Army."
A Humanist Scholar, Driven from his Home
The Provisional Executive Council, which governed Kosovo up until the
entry of NATO troops, represented every ethnic group in the province. On
August 8 we interviewed Bajram Haliti, one of the Council's members.
Haliti, a Roma, also serves as Secretary for Development of Information on
the Languages of National Minorities. Always well-dressed and dignified,
he was gentle and soft-spoken, and I took an immediate liking to this
scholarly man who described himself as a humanist. Two years before, he
published a book, "The Roma: a People's Terrible Destiny," concerning the
genocide against the Roma people during the Second World War, and he
kindly gave us each a copy of his book. In his personal library were over
500 books in many languages and from many countries on the subject of the
Roma and the genocide against them. Both of his homes were burned down by
KLA soldiers, including the library that Haliti had spent a lifetime
collecting. "I can't set a price on that library," he told us. At the
beginning of May 1999, Haliti sent an open letter to President Clinton,
protesting the bombing of his country. In the letter, he wrote, "Everyone
who cares for peace supports Yugoslavia, its leadership and people, who
are fighting for freedom, independence and territorial integrity." Calling
for an end to the bombing, his letter pointed out that "only peaceful
means can lead to a just settlement for all national communities which
live in Kosovo and Metohija." The letter made an impression. Haliti was on
the first travel ban list.
Addressing the issue of the rights of the Albanian people in Kosovo,
Haliti mentioned that a Yugoslav delegation arranged 17 meetings with
secessionists prior to NATO's bombardment. "In those negotiations," he
said, "we wanted to offer the Albanian people maximum legal, cultural and
political autonomy," but the secessionist delegation refused to meet with
them. "Every ethnic group was guaranteed all political, cultural and legal
rights," but secessionist Albanians boycotted institutions. "People
outside of Yugoslavia did not know that Albanians refused to exercise
their rights. For example, Albanians boycotted schools in their own
language, and told the world that they can't receive an education in their
own language." There were 65 newspapers in the Albanian language in
Kosovo, he added. "Many of these newspapers advocated secession, to sever
ties. Not one newspaper was forbidden. In America, if a group put out a
newspaper advocating secession and terrorism, would that newspaper be
allowed to publish?"
"Why doesn't NATO challenge [KLA leader] Hasim Thaci? Why don't they
bomb Hasim Thaci," he asked, "as he carries out massive ethnic cleansing?
In Kosmet [Kosovo-Metohija] now, few Serbs remain, few Roma remain and few
Gorans remain.... The Roma people are in a very hard situation. It is the
same situation Jewish people faced in 1939. At that time, Hitler
persecuted every Jew in his territory. And now we have Hasim Thaci. Now
Roma houses are burned down. Roma are expelled by the KLA."
"The hostility toward Roma people is because we want a normal life
together with other ethnic groups, we oppose division of our country, and
we give our political support to the government."
One of our delegation members, Ken Freeland, a pacifist and anti-war
activist from Houston, was keenly interested in a journal edited by
Haliti, Ahimsa, the title of which was taken from Gandhi's term for
non-violence. "Roma people are a peaceful people," Haliti explained. "The
Roma are a cosmopolitan people. Roma do not have a country. The exodus of
the Roma people has brought them to every country, where they are loyal
citizens who live a normal life. The Roma people have earned the right to
give this name to the journal."
Haliti told us that in a few months "we will have our own radio and
television frequencies, and a station" called Romany National Television,
and that he would be the station's chief editor. I wondered in how many
other countries Romas held government positions. How many other countries
had a Romany radio and television station, in the Romany language? Were
there any, besides Yugoslavia? NATO propaganda had turned reality
completely on its head, painting the most multiethnic society in the
Balkans, in which every nationality was represented in the Kosovo
government, as nationalist and racist.
Haliti and I shared a passion for music, and following our interview,
we had a very interesting discussion of Roma culture, and the contribution
of the Roma people to the world of music. Haliti told us the flamenco
music originated among Roma people, and also talked of several prominent
Roma musicians, such as jazz guitarist Django Reinhardt and flamenco
musician Camaron De La Isla.
Twelve days later, Haliti was again interviewed, this time by Tanjug,
the Yugoslav news agency. "It is useless to talk about the position and
the rights of Romanies, as the UN peace mission is unable to protect any
inhabitants of the province, including ethnic Albanians who do not accept
the terror of their extremist fellows," he declared. KLA leaders "reject
the fundamental democratic and humane principles on which contemporary
civilization rests and without which there can be no peace or stability in
multiethnic communities." It will be a long time before Bajram Haliti's
name is removed from the travel ban "enemies list."
War on Belgrade
One of NATO's innovations was a rather novel form of censorship. On
April 23, missiles slammed into Radio Television Serbia (RTS) in downtown
Belgrade, killing 16. The studio, NATO claimed, was a "legitimate military
target" because it broadcast "propaganda," meaning, of course, that it was
reporting the effects of NATO's bombing. RTS Belgrade was passing footage
of destruction to Western media, a practice that evidently had to be
stopped. CNN had a studio there, but was warned of the attack beforehand
and pulled out its equipment and personnel. CNN invited Serbian Minister
of Information Aleksandar Vucic to the studio for a live broadcast
interview. Vucic was asked to arrive for makeup at 2:00 AM sharp on April
23, for an interview scheduled to take place half an hour later. At 2:20,
RTS was no more. Sava Andjelkovic, who worked in the station, was reported
to have said, "A wall behind me virtually vanished, and then the entire
wing of the building. We heard screams of wounded people." Several people
were trapped in the rubble, and it was some time before all of the
survivors could be rescued. Vucic was more fortunate. His tardiness spared
his life, foiling the attempted assassination.
By the time of our visit, the rubble had been cleared, but the building
still stood with one wing sheared away, the multi-floor building standing
with each floor exposed. Nearby, missing railings and smashed windows at
the Dusko Radovic Children's Theater hinted at greater damage within.
RTS was not alone. Radio and television stations and towers throughout
Yugoslavia were targeted. Out host Nikola demonstrated what was on his
television. Only static could be found on the state channel. Untouched
were opposition channels, as well as music video and fashion channels, and
always there was access to Western cable. Western media stories about the
so-called "media dictatorship" in Yugoslavia, like all Western media
stories about Yugoslavia, are less believable for those who visit there.
We stopped at the Tanjug Press Center, housed in an aged and
unprepossessing building. As we climbed the stairs, delegation member
Michael Parenti pointed to several steps that were missing chunks of
concrete and quipped, "So this is the well-oiled Milosevic propaganda
machine we hear so much about." Not far away, an opposition-owned
television station, housed in a tall gleaming modern building, towered
above surrounding buildings. The U.S. and European Union have funnelled
millions of dollars to opposition media in Yugoslavia. One wonders what
the reaction would be in the United States were a hostile foreign
government to fund American media advocating the overthrow of the
government. In Yugoslavia, this media, bought and paid for, operated
freely. Newsstands were everywhere, and perusal revealed that a flood of
opposition newspapers and magazines vastly outnumbered pro-government
publications such as Politika, Borba, and Vecernje Novosti. It presented
an interesting study in semantics. A media dictatorship is where state
television cannot be viewed, but opposition television can; where there
are three pro-government papers and dozens of opposition papers. In the
United States, freedom of the press is lauded. One can pick up any
newspaper in any city with the confident expectation that it will have
essentially the same content as any other newspaper in any other city.
Alternative publications, often tepid and predictable, are marginalized
and often difficult to find, virtually to the point of irrelevance.
NATO's media war against Yugoslavia continues unabated. In place of
bombs, more subtle methods are implemented, outside the perception of the
American public. As state television returns to the air, transmitters
based in neighboring countries jam it. Such stations as Voice of America,
BBC, Radio Free Europe and USA Radio broadcast on Yugoslav state radio and
television frequencies. While we were in Yugoslavia, on August 11, RTS
issued a statement condemning this "media occupation," and pointing out
that these "frequencies were awarded to our country by international
conventions" and that this "violates all international standards in the
sphere of telecommunications." Appeals to international law fell on deaf
ears.
From RTS, a long trolley ride took us to the Belgrade suburb of
Rakovica. There we viewed the 21st of May Industrial Complex, which
manufactured automobile engines, and like many factories throughout
Yugoslavia, it lay in ruins. Now it was merely a mass of twisted wreckage;
steel pipes, girders and concrete jumbled together. The deliberate
targeting of factories was an extension of sanctions, an attempt at
economic strangulation. Over 600,000 people lost their jobs during the
period of bombing, raising the number of unemployed to over two million.
About $100 billion damage was inflicted on Yugoslavia, president of the
Trade Union Association Radoslav Ilic announced during the war. "This
aggression has all the characteristics of a dirty war," he said, "in which
workers are the biggest sufferers. Workers and the products of their work
have become military targets, and the international progressive public is
too slow in awakening." Much of the Western progressive public still
slumbers.
While in Rakovica, we met a refugee from Bosnia-Herzegovina who had
earlier worked in Germany for seven years. He wanted to show us his
child's school, the France Presern elementary school, one of dozens of
schools targeted by NATO. Virtually every window was broken and several
window frames were damaged. The doors were locked, so we were unable to
view interior damage. He told us that the school year would begin in two
weeks, and wondered where his child would go to school.
Kosovo's Other Albanians
Later that afternoon we met with three Albanian refugees from Kosovo.
All three, Faik Jasari, Corin Ismali and Fatmir Seholi, were members of
the Kosovo Democratic Initiative, an Albanian political party that favored
a multiethnic Kosovo within Yugoslavia and opposed the KLA's policy of
secession and racial exclusion. Jasari is president of the Kosovo
Democratic Initiative, as well as a member of the Provisional Executive
Council, which governed Kosovo prior to NATO's occupation of the province.
Jasari said he was forced to flee from his home in Gnjilane on June 18th
because "members of the KLA were showing photos of my family and me to
people, trying to find us. I am now at the top of the list of people the
KLA is looking for." Jasari lost everything. "My wife and I worked for 34
years, and now we have nothing. Nothing." Barry asked him if he was afraid
for his life. "Yes. I am afraid.....If they find me, they will kill me."
He had good reason to be afraid. The KLA had already killed several
hundred pro-Yugoslav Albanians. Many more were beaten and tortured. In
all, Jasari said, the KLA had expelled over 150,000 Albanians from Kosovo,
both before and after the entry of KFOR. He could not stand idly by, and
sent a letter to UN Special Representative for Kosovo Bernard Kouchner,
asking "to visit with him and discuss the situation in Kosovo and with my
party." Predictably, his letter went unanswered. "Where is democracy and
pluralism in Kosovo? I can't go there," he told us. I can't take part in
the political process. Where is democracy?" All of NATO's pretty-sounding
phrases about democracy and human rights, aimed at the Western domestic
audience, rang hollow for him.
When asked about reports of Serbian oppression of Albanians, Jasari
responded firmly, "It is not true. It is not true. I am Albanian and I
have all the same rights as any Serbian."
Corin Ismali, Under-Secretary for National Social Questions in the
Provisional Executive Council, also attempted to meet with Kouchner, and
he too was rebuffed. Ismali was forced from his home by threats from KLA
soldiers, he explained, "because I supported Yugoslavia and I opposed
secession....We want to live with other ethnic groups in Yugoslavia. We do
not want to live in a country that has only one ethnic group."
Fatmir Seholi worked in public relations for the Kosovo Democratic
Initiative, and was chief editor at Radio Television Pristina. "I must
point out," he said, "that the Albanian people had more media than did the
Serbian people" in Kosovo. "You could find only one newspaper in the
Serbian language, but you could find about 65 newspapers in the Albanian
language." That one Serbian newspaper was closed down shortly after the
arrival of KFOR in Kosovo. Seholi studied at Pristina University, and
pointed out that Albanian people were able to study in their own language.
"I think that America did not have the right information about Albanian
people in Kosovo, or did not want to get the correct information about the
rights of Albanian people in Kosovo."
The tragedy that befell Seholi's country had disillusioned him. "Until
the NATO bombing, I loved and sympathized with democracy in the United
States. After studying some facts about democracy in the United States and
about negotiations, I've learned that there is no democracy in the United
States." The U.S., he said, "supported and still supports KLA terrorism in
Kosovo. Two years ago, on a night in January 1997, the KLA killed my
father. He was called a traitor and killed only because he supported
Yugoslavia and the Serbian government, not the KLA regime. He loved living
with all ethnic groups in Kosovo." KLA soldiers tortured two of Seholi's
brothers. One day before Seholi left Kosovo, a woman from the KLA visited
him and "said that if I told people that my father was killed by Serbs, I
could have a high-ranking position in the KLA."
Seholi and his colleagues at Radio Television Pristina were tricked
into abandoning the station when KFOR concocted a phony story about a
planted bomb on the premises. KFOR then escorted Seholi to the border.
After the station was turned over to the KLA, it ceased broadcasting in
multiple languages. All programs now are solely in the Albanian language.
Seholi spoke eloquently of those killed by NATO bombs. Two convoys of
Albanian refugees returning to Kosovo were massacred, at Djakovica and
Korisa. "In every case, Albanians get hurt from all sides, but mainly from
NATO bombing....The man who could command NATO to bomb people is not
human. He is an animal. After the bombing at Djakovica, I saw decapitated
bodies. I have pictures of that. It is horrible, terrible. I saw people
without arms, without feet." Later, I saw disturbing photographs of these
victims. I could not view photos of the charred and mutilated victims
without becoming enraged. It is impossible to forget such images. "Who is
the evil man here?" asked Seholi. "Milosevic, who is protecting the
territory of Yugoslavia and protecting the people of Kosovo, or Clinton,
who bombs us?"
"Now we can see that the United States does not care about any ethnic
minority," Jasari added. "Before NATO started bombing us, they said they
are protecting the Albanians. You can see Albanians were the victims. If
they were protecting the Albanians as they said they were, they wouldn't
be bombing them.... The United States used the Albanian people as the
excuse for their aggression." Jasari wondered, "What kind of democracy is
it which kills people, kills innocent victims, bombs schools, bombs
bridges, buses full of people, and people living in their homes?"
All three rejected NATO's propaganda line concerning Yugoslav forces.
"The KLA is a terrorist group," Seholi explained, "and the Yugoslav Army
is our state's army. We do not think that our army killed villagers."
Jasari firmly stated, "Our Yugoslav Army exists to protect people, not
kill them. It's propaganda. The Yugoslav Army never attacked anyone in
Kosovo. They only defended themselves."
Preparation for War Masquerading as Peace Talks
Jasari was a member of the Yugoslav delegation during peace
negotiations in Rambouillet and Paris. Despite daily requests by the
Yugoslav delegation for face-to-face meetings, Western mediators would not
permit direct negotiations with the secessionist delegation. The Yugoslav
delegation could only meet with Western officials, who, Jasari pointed
out, "would not listen to anyone." Madeleine Albright was particularly
obstructionist. "She had her task, and she saw only that task," Jasari
said. "You couldn't say anything to her. She didn't want to talk with us
because she didn't want to listen to our arguments."
The composition of the two delegations reflected differing attitudes
regarding a multiethnic society. The secessionist delegation was comprised
solely of Albanians, whereas all of Kosovo's major nationalities were
represented on the Yugoslav delegation. Only a minority of the Yugoslav
delegation was Serbian. Western officials "were shocked," Jasari told us,
when they saw "not only Serbs, but also Roma, Albanian and Egyptian," as
well as Turkish, Gorani and Slavic Muslim representatives.
By the end of 17 days of negotiations at Rambouillet, the Yugoslav
delegation accepted the political proposals put forth, while the
secessionist delegation had not. Hours before the conclusion of the talks
at Rambouillet, the U.S. delegation unilaterally submitted 56 pages of new
proposals, bypassing the procedure for submission through the five-nation
Contact Group. The new plan was intended to thwart any possibility of a
peaceful settlement and thereby provide a pretext for bombing. It called
for occupation of Kosovo by NATO troops. A NATO-appointed Chief of the
Implementation could "recommend to the appropriate authorities the removal
and appointment of officials," and if elected officials were not removed
from office on demand, then the "Joint Commission may decide to take the
recommended action." If the Joint Commission failed to carry out its
orders, the plan specified that the Joint Commission could be supplemented
by NATO personnel when "needed for its implementation." "All facilities
and services," including "use of airports, roads, rails and ports,"
utilized by NATO would be supplied "at no cost" to NATO. Furthermore, NATO
would enjoy "unrestricted use of the entire electromagnetic spectrum."
Censorship would be imposed on the region, as the NATO-appointed Chief of
the Implementation would be responsible for "allocation of radio and
television frequencies." The plan granted to NATO personnel, "under all
circumstances at all times" complete immunity "in respect of any civil,
administrative, criminal, or disciplinary offenses which may be committed
by them." Perhaps the most crucial clause was in Appendix B, stating that
"NATO personnel shall enjoy, together with their vehicles, vessels,
aircraft, and equipment, free and unrestricted passage and unimpeded
access throughout the FRY [Federal Republic of Yugoslavia] including
associated airspace and territorial waters." Acceptance of this clause
would have brought NATO troops swarming over the entire territory of
Yugoslavia, interfering in every aspect of society and every institution.
NATO was determined to occupy and colonize not only the province of
Kosovo, but also the entire territory of Yugoslavia.
When peace talks later resumed in Paris, Western officials told the
Yugoslav delegation that no discussion would be permitted of the proposals
they submitted on the last day at Rambouillet. Only discussion relating to
implementation of the proposals was allowed. Western officials begged the
secessionist delegation to sign the plan, and behind the scenes they
assured them that disarmament of the KLA would be merely symbolic. Once
Western officials obtained the requisite signatures of the secessionist
delegation, they aborted the Paris conference and prepared to launch their
war of aggression against Yugoslavia. The entire peace process was a ruse,
designed to fail.
The Tortured South
It was time for us to travel to southern Serbia. Money was starting to
run low for some members of our team. After much effort, Barry was able to
find a travel company with a startlingly low rate that most could afford.
In time, though, the truth of the adage, "you get what you pay for," would
be reaffirmed. Within three minutes of our departure our driver drove us
into a dead end. "He's already lost," commented Ken. Our driver's solution
was direct, and indicative of things to come. Rather than back up, he
drove the van up onto and across a walkway. We travelled south along E-75,
the main highway linking Belgrade with Nis, Yugoslavia's third largest
city. The highway and bridges along the way were bombed at several points,
necessitating numerous detours, and our path was circuitous and
time-consuming. After an hour or so, our driver turned on the radio.
Whenever he tuned to a station playing wonderful Yugoslav music, he had
the annoying habit of instantly moving past it until he could alight on a
station broadcasting insipid American and Yugoslav rock music.
We arrived at Aleksinac shortly before noon. A small mining town with a
strong socialist local government, Aleksinac was targeted with a special
ferocity. Four times it was bombed. Local officials provided us with
statistics that were disturbing for such a small town: 767 houses and 908
apartment flats were bombed, as well as 302 public buildings. Dragoljub
Todorovic, a 74-year-old retired teacher, was at the opening meeting.
Metal braces encased his left leg and he walked with crutches. His home
had been obliterated in one of the attacks. "I had been told for 40 to 50
years that Americans were our friends," he said. "Americans, with
Russians, destroyed fascism together. I survived the Second World War. I
was a Partisan during the war." Now war had again visited Todorovic. "The
bombs dropped about 15 meters from my house," he told us. We were later to
see the site of his house. Nothing remained but blasted concrete and
bricks strewn about. "When I regained consciousness, I saw that only a
small part of skin connected my leg with my body," he said. Todorovic's
leg was saved through surgery, but he will remain crippled for the
remainder of his life. He was in the hospital for 14 weeks and suffered a
heart attack during his recovery. Enduring constant pain during his
hospital stay, he asked himself, "Is this American fascism? The worst way
possible - that was the way America chose." When we were at the site of
the ruins of Todorovic's home, a man approached to listen to our
interviews. He interjected that in World War II, "the Partisans saved
American pilots whose planes crashed here. And now they don't say thanks."
Indicating the rubble, Barry replied, "This is their thanks."
We strolled down Dusan Trivunac Street. Almost an entire city block on
this street was wiped out. Several houses were destroyed, and many killed
and wounded. Survivors reported hearing screams and cries for help
immediately following the blasts. Despite the staggering scale of
destruction here, all of the rubble had been entirely cleared away by the
time of our visit. The site was now a construction area. Neatly stacked
bricks and building materials bordered the area, and a dump truck and
towering crane stood ready, as workers were just departing for lunch. The
only sign of the block's fate was a neighboring apartment building,
scarred and pock-marked by shrapnel from the blast. Further down the
street, at the site of another explosion, the foundation for a new
building had already been laid.
We turned down Vuk Karadzic Street, and entered a charming neighborhood
of two story homes with red tile roofs and flowers lining the balconies.
On the night of April 5, several people lost their lives when bombs fell
at the end of the street. In a deposition taken two weeks later, Srboljub
Stojanovic described that night. "There was a terrific explosion," he
reported. "The windowpanes burst, the ceiling fell down on us, and the
walls collapsed, and this practically buried us. After that I could only
hear the screams and crying of my family members. My whole body was
injured." He and his family managed to dig their way out from under the
rubble. "There were heaps of various construction material, glass,
destroyed vehicles, and people coming out and trying to help those who
were buried. I could hear cries for help, crying, screams, calls, and all
this was horrific." The president of the Socialist Youth in Aleksinac, a
charming woman, acted as our translator and guide. She told us that she
still has frequent nightmares, dreaming that she hears an air raid siren,
and awakes thinking she is going to be bombed. Resident Zago Militic told
us that her entire family was injured in the attack. She cried as she told
us, "We have been friends [with Americans] until now. This is something
none of us expected. We always thought they were our friends. I am 65
years old, and now I must think about finding a new home." Photographs
taken on the day of the bombing showed a massive amount of destruction.
Like other sites in Aleksinac, this neighborhood was largely cleared of
rubble. A power shovel had scooped out most of the debris, and the ground
was freshly dug. Adjoining the area, one house had lost most of its roof.
Two apartment buildings stood in back of the area. Shrapnel had sprayed
them, leaving dozens of gaping holes and twisted windows. Standing alone
before them was a single wall, with a stairway leading nowhere; all that
remained of someone's home.
Missiles also struck the firm of Angrokolonijal on April 5. A night
watchman, Velimir Stankovic, was killed instantly. At the time of our
visit, the main storage building was locked and idle. We peered through a
hole, and saw that the interior was devastated. A construction inspector
had concluded that the building would have to be torn down. We were told
that this was a food-processing firm, supplying much of the food for
Aleksinac. The registration office near the gate was a ruin. Across the
street, much of the roof was torn from the commercial department auxiliary
building. A fence, twisted and bent, prevented us from going inside, but
what we were able to see from one end of the building hinted at massive
destruction inside. The construction inspection determined that these
buildings, too, would have to be demolished.
A very short walk led us to Empa, a worker cooperative that
manufactured streetlights and lights for factories and homes. On the
periphery of the blast radius at Angrokolonijal on April 5, it was again
bombed on May 28. In all, the plant sustained more than $300,000 damage.
The plant's director, Slobodan Todorovic, told us that one worker was
killed and another wounded. Air raid sirens were virtually a daily
occurrence here during the war, and workers stayed at their posts during
the bombing as a form of resistance to NATO.
We visited another neighborhood scarred by bombs and missiles. The
walls of several brick houses stood eerily unscathed, while nothing
remained of the roofs and interiors. One house appeared to have taken a
direct hit. Only a few walls remained, surrounded by piles of rubble.
Houses farther away were missing their roofs. Someone had placed a
memorial to one of the victims on a wall. We saw these memorials
everywhere we went in Yugoslavia. Single sheets of paper or cloth, posted
on walls and trees and telephone poles, with a photograph and name of the
person killed, along with a few comments. The victims were not forgotten.
In a communal society, every person killed was seen as a loss for the
whole community, not only for friends and family. One woman approached us
and spoke of those killed. One neighbor killed was Dusana Savic, a
technical manager in the local confectionary factory, which sustained
damage during the attack. "She was a very good neighbor," she said. "She
regretted that she never had children." I couldn't help dwelling on this
woman with her failed dream of parenthood. What other dreams did she have?
How could she know that one day all of those dreams would instantly
vanish, along with her life and all of its joys and struggles and everyday
pleasures? Our witness had a message for President Clinton: "I am not
guilty and my children are not guilty." Another woman spoke of a man named
Predrag Nideljkovic, killed when an explosion caused a wall to fall on
him. He built his home here only the year before. "He worked very hard in
the hospital to help people," the woman said. "He was not ashamed to do
anything. He did everything, from cleaning to managing the hospital. He
always had time to talk with people." He was a man of kind and gentle
disposition, she added. "We came out of hell," but NATO leaders will not.
She paused, as emotions welled up within her. "Predrag is here in my
heart," she whispered. A moment of silence fell, and then she broke into
tears.
Local officials of the Socialist Party took us to lunch at a restaurant
on the outskirts of Aleksinac. Even here, one couldn't escape reminders of
the horror that had visited the town. Across the street, a gas station
showed a fair amount of bomb damage. At my end of the table sat Zoran
Babovic, President of the Socialist Party in the Aleksinac municipality,
as well as other Socialist Party officials. Zoran's English was very good,
and Ken and I discussed the Yugoslav economy with him. Social property
plays a significant role in Yugoslavia. Large-scale industry is
state-owned, while most mid-sized firms are worker cooperatives. Most
farms are privately owned, but larger agricultural operations are worker
cooperatives. Following lunch, we decided to donate money to the town's
reconstruction fund. Our rapidly shrinking resources placed a severe
limitation on our contribution, but we gave what we could. They needed
hundreds of millions of dollars. We fell rather short of that figure.
We arrived in Nis at 6:00 PM. Our hotel overlooked the Nisava River and
an impressive Ottoman fortress built in the early 18th century. One of our
delegation members, Jaime Mendiata, accidentally got off the elevator on a
wrong floor and discovered that the second and third floors were given to
Roma refugee families. This was common throughout the entire territory of
Yugoslavia. Refugees were placed in hotels and the homes of volunteers,
and I couldn't help but think how much more humane this approach was than
placing people in tents.
The next morning, our van departed for Surdulica, well south of Nis.
Along the route, we passed through some of the most gorgeous scenery I've
ever seen. Rolling hills gave way to steeper hills and deep ravines.
Charming villages nestled on verdant hillsides. The road curved and
suddenly we were confronted with a scene that was all the more shocking
amidst this beauty. We were at Grdelica gorge. An imposing concrete
highway bridge was severed at two points. Passing under the highway bridge
at a nearly perpendicular angle, ran railroad tracks atop an incline. Some
distance down the track stood a steel railroad bridge, its girders and
tracks deformed by explosions. Underneath the highway bridge were strewn
four incinerated passenger train cars, reddened from intense heat. At the
bottom of the incline one car lay, collapsed like an accordion. Two cars,
still coupled, lay on their sides a few feet from the track. The fourth
car, directly under the highway bridge, was split in two pieces. The end
of the car was on one side of the track; a partial frame and little else
among the wreckage. The remainder of the car lay on the opposite side of
the track, collapsed and fragmented. Emotions flared within me as I viewed
the scene. No one inside these cars could have survived. I glanced down at
a dirt road at the base of the incline. An elderly man was walking with a
cane. He spotted us, and it was apparent he felt compelled to tell me
something. With great difficulty, he struggled with his cane to climb the
hill. When he reached the top, he walked over to me. "This was murder," he
said, simply and directly. "Four missiles struck here, and 17 people were
killed." He reminded me that a Yugoslav delegation had attempted to meet
secessionists for negotiations 17 times prior to the war. "We tried hard
to find a peaceful solution. We are a peaceful people." He talked of
Yugoslavia's 26 nationalities, adding that we could see for ourselves how
they live among each other. It was true. We had seen.
Seventeen bodies were found, but three additional people are listed as
"missing." The heat from the blasts was so intense that literally nothing
remained of those three. In autopsy photographs, the victims appear to be
little more than sticks of charcoal. Once seen, these photographs are
impossible to forget. Impossible, too, to forgive what was done. The
autopsy report for one unidentified man is typical. "The carbonization of
the head and neck transformed these parts of the body into a brittle,
black, and amorphous mass," it reads. Most of the body was carbonized, and
several body parts were missing. Similar descriptions can be found in
autopsy reports for the other victims.
The train was bombed on April 12, 11:40 AM, just three minutes after it
departed from the station in Grdelica. In a deposition taken three days
later, Bora Kostic described events that day. During the attack, he and
his family were in their house, located just 40 meters from the railroad
bridge. Sitting down to enjoy lunch, they heard the "extremely loud noise"
of a low flying jet aircraft. "I heard a tremendously loud explosion quite
near my house," he said, and "all doors and windows on the south wall of
my kitchen were dislocated by the blast and blown into the kitchen
together with their frames and broken glass." He and his family were
thrown against the northern wall of their kitchen, and Bora's wife
"sustained serious injuries." Bora and his son brought his wife, who was
"unconscious and heavily bleeding," outside, in order to take her to his
cousin's house, located at a safer distance. Bora saw the passenger train,
and "several people falling from the carriage down into the River Juzna
Morava." They were "not jumping off the train, but were falling
uncontrollably." The NATO jet wheeled around and made a second run at the
train. Some thirty seconds after the first explosion, "another extremely
loud explosion was heard. The impact was again on the two burning
carriages at the very exit of the bridge," and "the new explosion further
intensified the fire." The blast sent "small metal pieces" flying, as well
as "human tissue, organs and parts." Bora and his son were climbing a hill
with his wife when "we heard a third extremely loud explosion. I saw a
missile hitting the middle section of the right side of the highway
bridge." The force of the blast knocked them down, and when they got up
and continued on their way, a fourth missile struck the highway bridge.
After leaving his wife at his cousin's, Bora and his son returned to help
the victims. Ten minutes had passed, and ambulances and cars had already
arrived at the scene. When Bora returned to his home, he saw that his yard
was littered with "small pieces of human organs, tissue, blood, small
metal train parts and missile fragments."
Our van pulled in Surdulica, a small town of 13,000, at 10:30 AM. We
met with officials at Zastava Pes, an automotive electrical parts factory
that once employed 500. Annual exports from the plant at one time amounted
to $8 million. Sanctions not only interrupted export contracts, but also
prevented the import of materials, causing a 70 percent reduction in the
workforce. The staff at Zastava Pes told us that during the war, bombs and
missiles rained down on their town almost every day.
We were first taken to a sanatorium, located atop a heavily wooded hill
that overlooked the town. This sanatorium provided care for patients with
lung diseases and also served as a retirement home. Refugees were also
housed in two of the buildings. Shortly after midnight on the morning of
May 31, four missiles struck the sanatorium complex. Two missiles hit the
building housing refugees and patients, and one hit the nursing home. At
least nineteen people were killed: 16 refugees and three nursing home
residents. The actual number of victims cannot be ascertained, because
several of the body parts found were unrelated to the 19 identified
bodies. Thirty-eight people were wounded. We were told that the force of
the explosions was so powerful that body parts were thrown as far as one
kilometer away. Following the attack, body parts were hanging in tree
branches, and blood was dripping from the trees. By the time of our visit,
they had cleaned up, but we could still see clothes hanging from many
trees. Although only one missile struck the nursing home, it caused
enormous damage. We walked around to the back, on the building's
southwestern side. A section of the second floor was collapsed, and the
entire southwestern face showed extensive damage. Mounds of rubble lay at
the base of the building. On the northeast side of the complex, the
refugee and patient building bore a gaping hole in its faade, from which
a river of rubble had poured, like blood from a wound. We entered the
building and walked through its rooms. Debris littered the hallways, and
in several rooms we found scorched mattresses, clothes, and damaged
personal belongings jumbled together in disarray. Bricks and chunks of
concrete lay scattered around one room, along with an upturned sink. Shoes
and clothes were strewn among the rubble, and a loaf of bread rested
against a child's shirt. According to the on-site investigation report on
June 3, it took two to three days to dig the bodies from the rubble. An
area near the building, the report states, "was covered with parts of
human bodies, torn heads, arms and hands as well as bodies partly covered
with rubble material, dust, broken bricks, material from roof structure,
broken roof tiles, laths, doors and windows blown out." Farther away from
the building, several dismembered bodies were found.
We next visited a neighborhood obliterated by NATO bombs. As in
Aleksinac, a remarkable reconstruction was taking place. Every trace of
rubble was removed, and the earth smoothed over. A bulldozer and a grader
were parked nearby, and construction of two new homes had already begun.
Local residents came out and talked to us, showing us photographs taken in
the aftermath of the bombing. The extent of destruction was appalling. We
visited another neighborhood wiped out by NATO bombs. Here too, an
energetic rebuilding effort was underway. Smashed automobiles and
partially roofless homes were the only physical reminders of the tragedy.
Eleven people, including five children, died here on April 27. When air
raid sirens sounded that day, they took refuge in the strongest basement
on their street. That was the house the missile hit. I vividly recall
seeing a photograph on the Internet the next day. It showed the back of an
ambulance, doors thrown open. Inside were piled chunks of shapeless human
flesh, still smoking - all that remained of those 11 victims, the youngest
of which was 4 years old. A "humanitarian" war, NATO propagandists called
this. One man in the neighborhood told us that the house was hit as a
result of an errant missile. "They were trying to hit the water supply
plant nearby, with two missiles," he said. Another man, Zoran Savic, told
us, "The sirens sounded everyday. Every day they bombed Surdulica. The
bombs were very powerful." Some distance away was another of NATO's
targets, an Army barracks, abandoned during the war. I climbed atop a
mound of dirt and saw that it too was bombed. But NATO sprayed its bombs
and missiles liberally throughout Surdulica. The destruction of an empty
barracks was of doubtful military utility. The targeting of a water supply
plant was inhuman. There are no words to define the destruction of entire
neighborhoods. Fifty homes were destroyed on April 27, and 600 damaged.
We were invited to lunch, and followed our hosts to Vlasinska Lake,
located on a plateau near the Bulgarian border. Our vehicles climbed up a
winding road through stunningly beautiful mountains. My admiration of the
beauty was leavened by apprehension, as the sheer cliffs reminded me that
I lacked confidence in the ability of our driver. We ate a building not
far from the lakeside, where our hosts displayed the generous and warm
hospitality typical of this country.
We planned to stop at Vladicin Han on our return trip to Nis. The
combined effects of excellent food and wine soon meant that all of the
passengers fell into a slumber. I was tired too, but wanted to enjoy the
scenery. As we approached Vladicin Han, I reminded our driver to stop
there. "Nishta!" he exclaimed. By now we were driving by the town.
"Nothing?" I thought, "What does he mean 'nothing'?" There's a bombed
building and bridge right before our eyes. Again I urged him to stop.
"Nishta!" he repeated, pushing his foot down hard on the gas pedal and
accelerating rapidly. He understood me. The exchange awoke our translator.
We had already passed Vladicin Han, so I asked our translator to talk our
driver into turning around. Despite his best and determined effort, our
translator was unable to persuade our driver to stop, and eventually he
shrugged his shoulders and went back to sleep, while I sat and stewed.
About thirty minutes later, Barry awoke and asked me, "Are we almost to
Vladicin Han yet?" "We've passed it," I replied. Later that night, Barry
read a document put out by the Yugoslav Ministry for Foreign Affairs. "It
says here, " Barry told me, "that in Vladicin Han, over fifty percent of
housing facilities and state buildings have been destroyed or damaged." He
just shook his head.
Terror Bombing of Nis
We returned to Nis, a beautiful old city, carpeted with trees. On our
first night in Nis, we had met with university professor Jovan Zlatic.
During the war, Dr. Zlatic served as commander of the city's Civil Defense
Headquarters. He discussed with us the bombardment of his city, with
particular emphasis on the use of cluster bombs. The widely used U.S.-made
CBU-87/B cluster bomb is designed to open at a predetermined height,
releasing 202 bomblets over a wide area. As these bomblets explode in the
air, an area up to the size of a football field is sprayed with thousands
of pieces of shrapnel. Generally, cluster bombs do limited damage to
structures. They are anti-personnel weapons. Flying sharp metal fragments
are intended to tear human beings apart. Dr. Zlatic showed us a collection
of photographs of cluster bomb victims in Nis. Page after page of
civilians, lying in pools of blood, and then, worse, autopsy photographs.
What cluster bomb shrapnel does to soft human flesh is beyond imagining,
and an anguished silence fell over the room as Dr. Zlatic flipped through
the photographs. Viewing them was unbearable. Finally, Dr. Zlatic looked
up at us and softly said, "Western democracy."
Now we would have the opportunity to visit these scenes. On three
separate occasions, we walked down Anete Andrejevic Street and talked with
residents. In the early afternoon on May 7, several cluster bombs were
dropped on this and surrounding streets. Nine people died here that day,
and dozens were wounded. At one end of Anete Andrejevic Street is a
marketplace, and the street was crowded with shoppers when cluster bombs
burst over the neighborhood. The street was narrow, the buildings old and
appealing. Evidence of the explosions could be seen everywhere. Shrapnel
had left virtually every house pockmarked, and the walls of some homes
were gouged by hundreds of steel fragments. There was no place for
pedestrians to hide that day. One parked car hadn't moved since then. It
was still there, riddled with holes, it's tires flat, and glass covered by
plastic. A memorial to each victim was posted at the spot where each was
killed. At the corner of Jelene Dimitrijevic and Sumatovacka Streets, a
memorial was posted on a brick wall, commemorating Ljiljana Spasic, 28
years old when she was killed, and almost nine months pregnant. Shrapnel
killed not only her, but also her unborn child. Two memorials to Pordani
Seklic hung on the windows of the front door of the restaurant where she
worked. She was a cook there, and shrapnel tore through the restaurant's
roof that day and killed her while she worked. Only a few blocks away, a
yawning rupture marred a bridge over the Nisava River. It was another act
of malevolent vandalism on NATO's part. Our hotel, across the Nisava,
overlooked the neighborhood around Anete Andrejevic Street, and we walked
extensively throughout the area. It was completely residential. There was
nothing that could be remotely construed as a military target.
Repeatedly, we were struck by the warm and friendly attitudes people
everywhere displayed towards us. Many people told us, "We don't blame the
American people for this. We know they didn't support this. It's the
government that did this." A rare instance of resentment occurred while we
filmed the smashed ruins of the office building of So Produkt, a
distributor of salt products. As a man walked by, he stopped and with
controlled anger told me, "America is our enemy." I glanced at the ruins
of So Produkt. It did not seem a controversial point. Another occasion
occurred we visited the Jugopetrol fuel depot in Nis. Despite an
appointment, we were unable to tour the facility. I wasn't a participant
in the discussion, but my impression was that a few of the workers were
not disposed to watch Americans parading through their demolished
workplace.
The Clinical Center in Nis was another target of cluster bombs.
Hundreds of pieces of shrapnel shot through the hospital, causing the roof
of one section to collapse. When we arrived, workers on scaffolding were
laying bricks. They were in the final stages of reconstruction of the
hospital's exterior. The parking lot presented a disturbing site. There
were several burned hulks of automobiles. The interiors were blackened and
empty. Incendiary cluster bombs here created a fireball, engulfing the
parking lot. Five people died immediately, and nine more later died from
their wounds. Cluster bombs wounded a total of 70 people here and in the
area of the marketplace. We talked with a man who lived nearby. He told us
that in addition to the hospital, 20 houses were also damaged. The
incendiary effect brought to mind Djakovica, where NATO bombed a column of
Albanian refugees who were returning to Kosovo. NATO was anxious to
introduce the newly developed CBU-97 cluster bomb, designed to spray
shrapnel heated to intense temperatures, and ignite everything it hits.
Djakovica was one of the sites that served as a testing ground for the
CBU-97. It proved a success. Seventy-three were killed, with several
victims charred beyond recognition.
The state-owned DIN cigarette factory in Nis was bombed on four
occasions. One of the largest factories in Yugoslavia, it employed 2,500
workers. The factory's deputy managing director, Milivoje Apostolovic,
told us that among the munitions dropped on the factory were cluster
bombs. Workers found two cluster bomb fragments with messages scrawled on
them: "Do you still want to be Serbs?" and "Run faster." Apostolovic
estimated the damage to his factory at $35 million. There was a deliberate
attempt to smash this and other factories as part of a larger policy to
destroy Yugoslavia as an industrial economy. Nothing remained of the
tobacco storehouse. It was completely flattened. Two of the larger
buildings were substantially demolished. Merely to clear the rubble
appeared to be an imposing task. Several of the smaller buildings
sustained major damage. Bricklayers were busy reconstructing one of the
smaller buildings. Across the lane, the faade of a large building bore
the marks of a cluster bomb, hundreds of gouged holes spread across its
face.
One of our last stops in Nis was at the Elektrotehna warehouse. We were
told that this warehouse stored primarily electronic kitchen appliances.
It was destroyed by one missile on April 7. Virtually nothing remained but
the cement slab on which it was built. Rubble was strewn everywhere, and
most of the roof of a neighboring house was blown away. While we walked
through the debris, Jaime stepped on a board and a nail impaled his foot.
He was bleeding profusely, so our driver took him to a local clinic. There
they wrote prescriptions for a tetanus antitoxin and penicillin. We soon
joined Jaime at the clinic and when he emerged, he and two others went to
the dispensary to fill the prescription. Jaime inquired about the charge,
and was told there was none. Wanting to help, Jaime insisted on paying for
the medicine. He asked them to name a price, so they told him four
dollars. His final stop was at the hospital, to receive the injection. In
addition to treating Jaime's foot, the doctor also gave him a brief
checkup. There was no charge for any service. People are placed first,
including those from a nation that had just dropped bombs here.
Targeting the Economy
We arrived in the central Serbian city of Kragujevac several hours
later than planned, due to an overly ambitious schedule and the delay
caused by Jaime's injury. Despite our belated arrival at Zastava factory
in Kragujevac, management staff had waited patiently and was there to
greet us. Zastava was the largest factory in the Balkans, and certainly
the largest I've seen. Primarily a manufacturer of automobiles and trucks,
Zastava supplied 95 percent of automobiles operating in Yugoslavia. This
diverse factory also produced tools, machinery and hunting rifles.
It was far too tempting a target for NATO. Shortly after the inception
of NATO's war, workers at Zastava organized human shields to protect the
plants. Zastava workers sent an open letter to the public of NATO
countries and email messages to Western leaders and NATO, notifying them
of their action. Their letter proclaimed that "we, the employees of
Zastava and citizens of freedom-loving Kragujevac, made a live shield,"
and that workers would remain in the factory "to protect with their bodies
what provides for their and their families' living." In the early hours of
April 9, NATO sent its reply to the workers' letter, in the form of bombs
and missiles. Miraculously, no one was killed, but 140 workers were
wounded, 30 of them seriously. One woman lying on a stretcher, her head
bandaged, said, "I can only tell Clinton, we will will build a new
factory. He cannot destroy everything." Three days later, Zastava endured
another onslaught. The six largest plants at Zastava lay in ruins.
According to Dragan Stankovic, export director for Zastava, the factory
complex in Kragujevac employed 28,000, and an additional 8,000 in
associated Zastava factories throughout Yugoslavia, most of which were
also bombed. Stankovic pointed out, "Of all the catastrophes that befell
us, we consider the humanitarian catastrophe to be the biggest." One of
the components of this catastrophe, he felt, was that workers in many
factories depended on Zastava, and with its destruction they and their
families, 200,000 people in all, were left without a means of livelihood.
Zastava's director, Milosav Djordjevic, ruefully concluded, "On the nights
of the 9th and 12th of April, all our dreams were destroyed in a mere 15
minutes of bombing." It was difficult for him to understand the mentality
that could inflict death and destruction. "We couldn't believe that some
people exist who would kill other people." It was all too easy for me to
believe, after months of exposure to the ranting of Madeleine Albright,
Bill Clinton, Tony Blair and Jamie Shea. Stankovic personally witnessed
the attacks on April 9th. He was in his apartment during the first
detonations at 1:40 AM, which felt "like an earthquake." Approximately
eight hours later, he was on the grounds of Zastava when the second
assault came. "I saw a series of mushroom clouds," he said, "a series of
mushroom clouds, strong light and fire, like an atomic bomb." Strangely,
he could hear neither the aircraft nor the explosions. "You could see the
explosion and big fires only. You couldn't hear anything."
The power plant at Zastava supplied electricity, compressed air, hot
water and steam for production throughout Zastava. The destruction of the
power plant had a wider impact, though, as it also provided heat and
energy for the city of Kragujevac. Stankovic told us that "about 15,000
flats, schools, hospitals and other institutions depend on the Zastava
power plant for their heat." One massive bomb exploded about 20 to 30
meters over the plant, ripping the roof from the building. "Smashed," a
power plant worker said, "Everything was smashed. We have removed
everything to be repaired." The resumption of production at the power
plant was an urgent task, and they had cleared all of the rubble. Two of
the eight turbo-compressors had already been repaired. The plant's
transformers were damaged, and two tons of highly toxic pyralene had
soaked into the ground and a nearby river. Adding to the ecological woes,
depleted uranium weapons exploded here.
Four bombs left the forging plant in ruins. Here components for
automobiles were forged, as well as agricultural machinery and railways.
Gone entirely was the roof. Mounds of rubble, damaged machinery, and
twisted girders confronted us. Scraps of metal debris hung in clumps from
isolated and deformed steel bars. The three-story office section of the
forging plant had also taken a direct hit, and a large section was blown
away. What remained of the upper floors sagged severely. The old forging
factory was adjacent, and it presented a stark appearance. Built in 1936,
its heavy concrete walls bore the scars of explosions, and its roof was
largely missing. When a missile exploded here, concrete columns fell on
the heat treatment area, and chunks of concrete and steel were sent
flying, injuring several workers.
Djordjevic felt that the paint shop was the pride of Zastava,
containing modern robotic production lines. Here the devastation was, if
anything, even more extreme than in the other plants. The awesome level of
destruction was shocking. Four bombs left the plant roofless and buried in
a carpet of rubble. Mountains of twisted and jumbled wreckage rose above
the rubble, as if they were abstract sculptures. Djordjevic lovingly
described the advanced technology used in this plant, adding, "They hit
this directly, as you would hit a man in the heart."
The automobile assembly plant was hit with depleted uranium weapons.
"Only depleted uranium can do this," Djordjevic told us, and he showed us
thick steel supports that were burned through by DU, "as if cut by
welding." Here too, the level of destruction was beyond imagination.
Merely to clear away the rubble would be a monumental task. Fifty-four
workers in the plant were injured by the blast and from the collapsing
roof. The plant, Djordjevic said, "was very beautiful to see when it was
functioning. Now look at it. It's a sorrow to see."
It was nearing 9:00 PM, and it was too dark to see the truck plant and
tools factory, both of which were completely demolished. We were instead
taken to the computer center, and they projected vehicle headlights onto
the building. It was completely smashed. The force from two bombs was so
massive that it raised the building from its foundation, before it
collapsed. Two IBM computers, costing $10 million, were lost. The total
destruction at Zastava is estimated at $1 billion. The Yugoslav government
is financing its reconstruction, and negotiations were recently undertaken
with South Korea's Daewoo for a joint venture in car manufacturing. In
order to meet the society's immediate needs for automobiles, the import of
used cars has been liberalized.
It was an exhausting day, and we had a long drive back to Belgrade. Not
long after our departure, I fell asleep. Some time later, I was jolted
awake by panicked screams, "Watch out! Watch out! Watch out!" It was not
the best way to wake up. I opened my eyes and the impetus for the cries
was immediately evident. We were in the right lane of a two-lane road.
Directly ahead of us in our lane was a stalled van, with two people
standing nearby. A bus, on our left and slightly behind, was starting to
pass us. A good driver would have applied the brakes, let the bus pass,
and then change lanes. Our driver maintained his fast speed, barrelling
toward the stalled van at an alarming rate. "So this is it," I thought.
"This is how I die." My next thought was that all of the documentation we
had collected would never make it the United States; then that people back
home won't know what became of me. No more than ten seconds remained in my
life, and time stretched, every second seeming an eternity. I had time to
reflect. I recalled a pleasant cruise on the San Francisco Bay and the
seagulls' calls above me. My last thoughts were of my loved ones. Time had
slowed down in a remarkable way. I no longer heard the cries of my
friends. Either they had fallen into silent contemplation, or I simply no
longer heard them. We were closing in on the van, and the bus was directly
beside us. Our driver tried to shove the bus off the road. The only sound
I heard was a long sustained blast of the horn by the bus driver, as he
was pushed half off the road. Now it appeared that only the right half of
our van would collide with the stalled van. The side I was sitting on.
Only a moment before impact, our driver pushed the bus further off the
road, but collision still seemed unavoidable. Blam! The sound was
deafening. I was still alive. Our van had managed to squeeze between the
two vehicles, but the rear view mirror was torn violently away. I could
only wonder what damage was done to the stalled van, as our driver failed
to stop, still maintaining the same speed. I hoped that the two people
were uninjured. About an hour later, Barry asked me to collect a tip from
everyone for our driver. I raised my eyebrow. When I went to the back of
the van and asked for tips, Ken was aghast. "Are you out of your mind?" he
asked me. "He almost killed us!" Long after the incident, my heart was
still pounding uncontrollably. We only lived through several seconds of
terror. What then, must it have been like for people here to live through
78 days of terror? At the end of the night, my roommates Jaime and Ken and
I were preparing for bed. Ken playfully suggested, "We ought to have
awards, best dressed and so on." Jaime quickly nominated our van driver
for the kamikaze award.
We are all Human Beings
Earlier in the week, I contacted Jela Jovanovic, general secretary of
the National Solidarity Committee, and she arranged for us to meet Serbian
refugees from Kosovo housed at Hotel Belgrade, on Mt. Avala, not far from
Belgrade. We met at her home, and then we walked to the home of Ileana
Cosic, who would act as our translator. Ms. Cosic is a playwright, critic
and interpreter, and we found her to be warm and delightful company. She
was a marvelous storyteller, and I enjoyed her stories during the taxi
ride to Mt. Avala.
When we entered Hotel Belgrade, the misery was immediately apparent.
Children were crying and conditions were overcrowded. We were shown all
three floors, and the anger among the refugees was palpable. Virtually
everyone had a loved one who was killed by the KLA. All of them had lost
their homes and everything they owned. At first, many refugees refused to
talk with us, and one refugee demanded of me in an accusing tone, "Can you
get my home back?" It wasn't until much later that we discovered that
there was a misunderstanding. We had been introduced as collecting
evidence for Ramsey Clark, and the refugees thought we were from NATO
General Wesley Clark. Once the misunderstanding was cleared up, we were
able to conduct interviews, although there was residual reluctance based
on their three prior experiences with Western visitors, all of whom
treated them with arrogance and contempt. Several of the refugees were too
upset to talk. At one point I asked to interview a young girl whose father
was killed by the KLA, and the girl ran from the room in tears. The eyes
of one woman and her son still haunt me. The woman told me that the KLA
murdered her husband. She didn't need to tell me. I could see it in her
eyes and her son's eyes. I could see everything in their eyes, all that
they had suffered. Every refugee in this hotel was from the Suva Reka
municipality, and by the time of our visit, the KLA had driven out or
killed virtually every Serb in Suva Reka.
In one room on the third floor, eight family members resided in one
room, their mattresses laying side by side from one end of the room to the
other. An 80-year old man reclined on a mattress, his cane nearby. His
silence conveyed an aura of sorrow. Mitra Dragutinovic wondered, "Why did
the Americans and the Germans come? Why did they come? Did they come to
protect us, or did they come to massacre us, to drive us from our homes,
to violate our women, and to kill our children?" She pointedly remarked,
"I can't believe that someone who had first bombed you for three months,
every day and for 24 hours, that after that he will come to protect you. I
wonder how Clinton can't be sorry for the children, at least. Are there
children in your country? Does he know what it means to be a child?"
Nikola Ceko had an expressive manner when he spoke. "No one is taking
care of us. KFOR. Nothing! They couldn't care less for poor Serbs," he
told us. "It's a shame for KFOR, for the United States, for Great Britain,
for France, for Germany, and all the big powers of the world. We are all
human beings. We have the right to live. The nationality, the race and the
religion are not important at all. A human being should first be a human
being. A true human being is the one who is ready to help the victim in
need."
The KLA had kidnapped two of Biljana Lazic's brothers and eight of her
cousins. Over one year had passed, and still there was no word of their
fate. "We were afraid of the KLA," she told us, "and we wouldn't allow our
kids to leave our houses. They were all locked inside. We didn't allow the
children to play outside at all. We were particularly afraid for the
children. The situation was unbearable. We had to flee, to save the
children at least."
Before the war, during the period when the OSCE Kosovo Mission was
present, Stana Antic's 13 year old son was kidnapped by the KLA while he
was on his way to visit an aunt and uncle. When Antic asked OSCE Kosovo
mission head William Walker to intervene, he told her that in order for
her son to be freed, she would have to replace him as a hostage of the
KLA. Shortly thereafter, the boy was murdered by his captors.
When Dostena Filipovic fled from her home, she and her family went to
another village, but saw that people there were also fleeing. The roads
were packed with refugees, and she was trapped in Prizren for some time.
While in Prizren, KLA soldiers fired on her column of refugees, but KFOR
troops there did nothing. Later, the refugees stayed overnight in a
village, where KFOR disarmed them and handed their guns over to KLA
soldiers.
The KLA had decimated Boze Antic's family and circle of friends.
Several friends and family members were ambushed on their way to do repair
work at the 14th century Holy Trinity Monastery. After KLA soldiers killed
their driver, they pushed the car down a cliff. Then they climbed down and
pumped several bullets into the survivors. Not long afterwards, KLA
soldiers looted the Holy Trinity Monastery, then burned it. One month
later, they dynamited the remains of the monastery, one of over 75
historic churches and monasteries in Kosovo demolished by the KLA. Several
date back to the Middle Ages, and some are UNESCO-designated world
historic sites. "If someone is human, he should at least be sorry for the
little children who have been murdered," pleaded Antic. "Because all of
the children of this world are children in the first place, regardless of
their religion, race and ethnic origin. What is the future of our children
now? They have no homes."
Sava Jovanovic showed us photographs of his demolished home. Scrawled
on one wall was 'UCK', the Albanian initials for 'KLA.' Another message
read, "Return of Serbs prohibited." He and his four brothers lived in
houses next to each other. Now, nothing remained of their farm. Sava's
father stayed behind to protect their property, but there was no word of
his fate. One month after I returned to the United States, I read a report
from Tanjug about the refugees in Hotel Belgrade. Sava had finally
received news of his father. Albanian criminals had lynched him..
Following the interviews, we returned to the home of Ileana Cosic, and
she kindly gave me a copy of her play, "Requiem for Destroyed Destinies."
Later I read the play, and was struck by a passage in which the
protagonist says, "When I think of my foster parents, their intellectual
refinement and dignity, I can't say how lucky they were to have died in
time..." I remembered my cousin Rob expressing similar sentiments about
his father; glad that he didn't live long enough to see the dissolution of
his country. Perhaps Westerners can't understand the depth of pain
Yugoslavs carry in their hearts because of the dismemberment of their
country. My grandparents on my father's side left Bosnia-Herzegovina for
the United States in 1912, just four years after the province was annexed
by Austria-Hungary. My grandfather emigrated in order to avoid being
drafted into the army of the oppressor. Two years later, Austria-Hungary
invaded Serbia, and ultimately one quarter of the entire population of
Serbia would perish in the world war. All my life, I dreamt of visiting
Yugoslavia, but it was beyond my financial means until the old Yugoslavia
was no more. This was my first trip, and it felt like a return home. This
communal society was a vivid reminder of what matters in life: family and
friends. My imagination, though, never conjured such circumstances for my
visit: a nation choked by sanctions and pummelled by thousands of bombs
and missiles. The spirit of the people was undiminished, however. In
conversation with one man in Novi Sad, I mentioned that NATO's invasion
plan called for a two-pronged attack: one advance from the south, through
Kosovo, and the second thrust from the north, through Vojvodina. His city
lay squarely in the path of the planned invasion. He responded that the
entire nation was determined to resist a NATO invasion. "Ordinary people,
without arms," he said, "would have fought NATO with their bare teeth." I
interpreted our frequent encounters with posters of Che Guevara in
Belgrade as another manifestation of the spirit of resistance. At the
beginning of the war, people formed human chains, their arms linked
together, to defend their bridges. There was a widespread commitment to a
multiethnic society, in defiance of NATO's attempts to carve up the region
into small mono-ethnic colonies. There was a determination to resist
domination by NATO. These were the people who struggled for five centuries
to free themselves from occupation by the Ottoman Empire, and they knew
something NATO didn't. History is long, and occupation and colonization
cannot be permanently imposed.
War's End
After the end of the war, Western reporters expressed surprise that
after 78 days of bombing, NATO had succeeded in destroying only 13
Yugoslav tanks. Yugoslav troops withdrawing from Kosovo appeared
untouched. NATO's grandiose claims of military success fell like a house
of cards. Camouflaged weaponry eluded NATO bombs, while dummy tanks,
bridges and missile emplacements were repeatedly hit. Microwave ovens with
open doors and burning automobile tires attracted Tomahawk missiles. Rolls
of black plastic sheeting were unfurled to mimic highways,
indistinguishable from the real thing for high-flying aircraft. Before the
war, the Yugoslav Air Force quickly and efficiently redeployed 50,000 tons
of materiel over a total of 6 million miles. NATO was outsmarted.
Perplexed commentators in the West wondered why Yugoslavia agreed to
withdraw from Kosovo, given NATO's abject failure. The most powerful
military force ever assembled failed to defeat the army of a small nation.
It seemed a mystery.
It wasn't a mystery for people in Yugoslavia. Surely aware of its
failure, NATO almost immediately resorted to a campaign of terror bombing.
Every town and every city in Yugoslavia was a target, and the entire
territory was saturated with bombs. The evidence was everywhere we went,
and what we saw constituted only a small fraction of the total
destruction. It would have taken months to witness it all. Terror bombing
prepared the way for final negotiations, when European Union mediator
Martti Ahtisaari, accompanied by Russian envoy Viktor Chernomyrdin,
visited President Milosevic on June 2. According to Ahtisaari, "at the
cost of a major effort," prior to the meeting, "we achieved a final
communiquÈ, signed by both the Russians and by the Americans." Russian
acquiescence, he felt, placed Milosevic "in a corner."
Ljubisa Ristic, director of the Yugoslav United Left, described the
final negotiations in an interview for the June 7, 1999 issue of Il
Giornale. A close colleague of President Milosevic, Ristic's party is a
coalition partner with the Socialist Party. On the evening of June 2,
Ahtisaari opened the meeting by declaring, "We are not here to discuss or
negotiate," and he and Chernomyrdin read the text of the plan. Milosevic
accepted the papers, and inquired, "What will happen if I do not sign?"
Ahtisaari swept his arm across the table that separated them, pushing
aside a vase of flowers. "Belgrade will be like this table," he declared.
"We will immediately begin carpet-bombing Belgrade. This is what we will
do to Belgrade," and he repeated the gesture. A moment of silence passed,
and then Ahtisaari added, "There will be half a million dead within a
week." According to Ahtisaari, when Milosevic then asked about
modifications to the plan, he told him, "No. This is the best that Viktor
and I have managed to do. You have to agree to it in every part."
Chernomyrdin's silence confirmed that the Russian government would do
nothing to oppose carpet-bombing. President Milosevic met with leaders of
the governing coalition, and they agreed that Yugoslavia had no
alternative. Three weeks later, in a speech delivered before both chambers
of the Assembly, Yugoslav Prime Minister Momir Bulatovic announced that
"diplomatic mediators....spoke of future targets to be bombed, including
civilian victims counted in the hundreds of thousands." Contrary to
Western leaders' demonization of President Milosevic, their terrorist
threat revealed that they expected him to possess more humanity than they
themselves did, and to accept the plan in order to avoid a bloodbath.
Occupation
It wasn't long before NATO violated the peace agreement. While NATO
dawdled over entering Kosovo, the KLA went on a rampage, looting and
burning homes, murdering and expelling thousands of Serbs, Roma, Turks,
Muslims, Gorans, Egyptians, and pro-Yugoslav Albanians. Milosevic was
livid, and shortly after midnight on June 17, he phoned Ahtisaari and
complained that NATO's delay in entering Kosovo allowed the KLA to
threaten the population. "This is not what we agreed," he argued. It
hardly mattered. Once NATO troops entered Kosovo, they did nothing to
deter KLA attacks against the populace. The KLA was free to carry out its
pogrom against all non-Albanians and pro-Yugoslav Albanians. Several
refugees testified to us that many attacks took place in the presence of
KFOR. Arrests are rarely made, and those arrested are usually released
within hours. Yugoslav security forces, under constant bombardment, were
castigated in the Western media when it took a few weeks for them to
restore order in most of Kosovo. No one is dropping bombs on KFOR, yet
after several months they have not even attempted to restore order. NATO
Lt. General Mike Jackson excused this inaction with the comment, "It is a
reality that KFOR cannot be everywhere all the time." Disarmament of the
KLA was a farce. Russian military and diplomatic sources report that this
was "a mere decorative step." Fewer than 5,000 weapons, mainly obsolete,
were turned in by the September 19, 1999 deadline, although KLA forces
numbered at least twice that. "A larger part of their armaments is
actually kept in the KLA's depots," the sources said. Meanwhile, police
have discovered KLA arms caches hidden in the hills of Macedonia. KLA
soldiers openly carry automatic rifles. KFOR's response to disorder was to
create a new police force, comprised almost entirely of members of the
KLA. Other KLA members have also joined the newly created Kosovo
Protection Corps, an organization of vague purpose, lightly armed but
permitted to keep its heavy weaponry in storage. UN and NATO officials are
fully cognizant of the nature of their creation. A United Nations internal
confidential report, dated February 29, 2000, admitted that the Kosovo
Protection Corps engages in "criminal activities - killings,
ill-treatment/torture, illegal policing, abuse of authority, intimidation,
breaches of political neutrality and hate-speech." NATO has seized a
multiethnic province, and turned it into a mono-ethnic and racist state,
policed by criminals.
For all the rhetoric, the war was never about "human rights," that
amorphous term that never seems to apply to U.S. client states. One man I
talked with was closer to the truth when he told me, "I think our
President Milosevic is more of a problem for imperialism than for us."
This truth slipped out during a speech President Clinton delivered on the
day before he started bombing. Buried in the bombast about human rights,
he declared, "If we're going to have a strong economic relationship that
includes our ability to sell around the world, Europe has got to be a
key.... Now, that's what this Kosovo thing is all about." The war was
merely an extension of long-standing policy. During the Conference on
Security and Cooperation in Europe in early 1992, Vladimir Pavicevic,
chief of the Yugoslav delegation, was confronted by aggressive Western
demands. Some Western diplomats told him that "additional pressure must be
exerted to achieve the goal, regardless of the consequences." Western
diplomats, Pavicevic claimed, were applying "pressure for us to fit into
the new European order. The United States wants Yugoslavia within the
framework of the new international order, and certainly not opposed to it.
It has been saying this both publicly and in conversation." And now they
say it with bombs. On June 10, 1999, the Western-sponsored Stability Pact
for Southeastern Europe issued a declaration calling for "creating vibrant
market economies" in the Balkans, and "markets open to greatly expanded
foreign trade and private sector investment." An independent and socialist
Yugoslavia in the heart of the Balkans is impeding the grand scheme to
integrate the entire region within the new economic model, in which the
region's interests would be subordinated to those of Western corporations.
No opportunity is missed. Chapter 4a of the notorious Rambouillet plan
stipulated that "the economy of Kosovo shall function in accordance with
free market principles," and allow for the free movement of international
capital. Having seized Kosovo, Western forces have set about the task of
dismantling the social economy and ensuring secession. Installing a new
monetary regime is seen as a linchpin of the effort, and Western
administrators recently opened the Micro Enterprises Bank, chiefly
financed by Germany and the Netherlands. On September 3, 1999, Bernard
Kouchner, head of the U.N. mission in Kosovo, decreed that the German mark
would replace the Yugoslav dinar as the official currency in the province.
Anyone using the dinar would be required to pay a penalty fee with each
transaction. The largest lead and zinc mines in all of Europe are located
at Kosovoska Mitrovica. Owned by the Yugoslav firm Trepca, the mines, as
well as its silver and gold mines and factories throughout the province,
will be operated under the U.N. Kosovo administration. NATO soldiers
dismissed management officials at every state enterprise in Kosovo,
replacing them with secessionists. On July 6, 1999, armed NATO and KLA
soldiers expelled the entire workforce from Jugopetrol in Kosovo Polje.
Coal reserves in Kosovo are estimated at 15 billion tons, the largest in
the Balkans. These mines, too, were seized. Discussions on privatization
are underway, and corporations are positioning themselves to pick up the
spoils. U.S. Metals Research Group Corp. signed a contract on July 30,
1999, for a concession on four copper mines in Albania. The firm's
president, Robert Papalia, commented, "Our hope is that starting from
Albania, we can also in the near future see what is available and what we
can do in the surrounding areas such as Macedonia, Kosovo and Montenegro."
A People Unbowed
The war ended only two months before our visit, yet we witnessed a
miracle. A remarkable reconstruction was taking place. Damage to the Beska
Bridge, on the highway linking Belgrade with Novi Sad, had already been
repaired. There was no sign of damage. Rubble had been removed at
Aleksinac and Surdulica, and construction of new houses begun.
Responsibility for reconstruction was assigned to the Serbian Directorate
for National Recovery when it was formed just ten days after the war's
inception, and they immediately launched an energetic program. By the end
of the year, 27 highway bridges and four railway bridges were rebuilt,
including the railway bridge at Grdelica. Over 300 housing units were
reconstructed, as well as four heating plants and four schools. An
additional 121 construction sites were opened, and work started on 600
more housing units. People who lost their homes in the bombing were given
keys to their fully furnished, newly built homes. The oil refinery at Novi
Sad, devastated by repeated attacks, already resumed production only two
weeks after our visit. By March 1, 2000, all plants but one at the Azotara
fertilizer complex in Pancevo were reopened. In Novi Sad, a new Varadin
Bridge is scheduled to be completed by November 1, 2000. The most
astounding news, though, was the resumption of production at Zastava.
Given the awesome level of destruction we witnessed, this news was almost
beyond my comprehension. I can only assume that production was shifted to
the less damaged and smaller plants. That would still entail
reconstruction of machinery on a heroic level, overcoming a
sanctions-induced lack of spare parts. By January 2000, eighty percent of
the rubble was cleared at Zastava. The following month, Zastava
manufactured over 1,200 automobiles, 750 of them for export, and resumed
limited production of commercial trucks. The entire nation has thrown
itself into the task of rebuilding. We saw only the beginnings of this
effort, but even those first efforts deeply impressed me. It was
singularly inspiring, as nothing else I've ever seen. This is a people
that will not be defeated.
For 78 days, tiny Yugoslavia held out against an onslaught by 19 of the
most powerful nations in the world. The world has descended into an ugly
barbarism. During an era when the world trembles before Western power,
forced to follow its dictates, Yugoslavia gave an example of independence
to the world. A portion of its territory was torn away and occupied, but
it defeated NATO's attempt to destroy and seize the entire nation. The
brutality of the West and its quest for economic domination, and the
example of Yugoslavia defending its independence and sovereignty, alone
and isolated, has opened the eyes of hundreds of millions of people
throughout the world. Many have been compelled to cast aside old illusions
about Western democracy. If only a few of the world's nations and peoples
are inspired to defend their own independence and sovereignty, then
Yugoslavia will have done the entire world and all of humanity a great
service.
On our last day in Belgrade, Danka gave us a message. "I hope this will
be the last time that someone is bombed just for some uncertain dirty
political goals. The real victims of bombing are just ordinary people,
mothers, children, and elderly people. I do not wish for anyone to go
through what we went through. None should suffer for the foolishness,
self-admiration or vanity of politicians."
Copyright 2000 Gregory Elich, All Rights Reserved
Copying and
distribution of the article is permitted, but no changes to the text are
allowed.